I'd love Hudson, but he's just so darn valuable as a two-inning guy in the 7th and 8th. It's a really tough call. I don't trust Payamps either. It might have to be Hudson or by committee, as you mentioned.
I know people are hating on Jackson right now, but at least he gives you a good power option. I understand Dunn had a lot of homers in the minors, but Jackson doubled off this guy yesterday. Oh well.