Its an interesting mix because each of the three players are really in their own lane. Peterson being the vet who was consistent when called upon, Brousseau being a bit of an unknown in regard to consistency, and Reyes being a young guy with upside and something to prove.
Personally, if it looks like Urias won't be out very long, I'd opt for Reyes or Brousseau in a 'high risk, high reward' situation. Might just discover something special.