Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
  • Brewers News & Analysis

    Milwaukee Brewers Free-Agent Pitching Target: Cal Quantrill

    As tempting as many fans might find it to dream on a more glamorous-than-usual offseason, the reigning World Series champions are likely to have a disciplined and opportunistic one. That doesn't mean they won't seek an upgrade for their pitching depth.

    Matthew Trueblood
    Image courtesy of Rick Scuteri-Imagn Images

    Brewers Video

    Although the Brewers believe in Kyle Harrison as a starter for 2027 and expect to get Quinn Priester back right away next spring, the team could use more starting pitching depth than they currently have in the organization. Maybe they'll bring back Brandon Woodruff—top executive Matt Arnold said Woodruff entered the offseason healthy and that he expects the veteran righthander to "be great next year"—but that's far from promised. At the moment, the team only has Jacob Misiorowski, Logan Henderson and Robert Gasser written into their 2027 rotation in pen; everyone else will have to prove their health and/or their capability.

    The need they face isn't acute enough to prompt them to behave unusually, though, and not just because they're still basking in the afterglow of winning the World Series. They circled back to talk with Dustin May after the righthander became a free agent, but they were not serious bidders for his services, a source close to May said. Nor are they likely to court even second-tier free-agent arms like Freddy Peralta, Trevor Rogers, or Michael King. They weren't involved in Sonny Gray's free agency before Gray signed with the Minnesota Twins Wednesday. They might not even go for the likes of Foster Griffin, Kaima Taira or Clay Holmes.

    One tier further down, though, some more plausible fits begin to show up. One pitcher who fits the Brewers to a 'T' is the resurgent Cal Quantrill, who cut his ERA in half and then some (from 6.04 in 2025 to 2.86) in 2026. Quantrill, 31, is the kind of starter the Brewers have often signed in past offseasons, and he would be an addition good enough to reinforce them for 2027 without interfering with any of their long-term plans.

    No team likes to lean on the fastball more than the Brewers, and Quantrill has become a three-fastballs guy who relies heavily on those offerings. For most pitchers, learning to throw all three fastballs means finding a sinker or a cutter, but those were the two heaters with which Quantrill was most comfortable for most of his career. It was the four-seamer that emerged as a far more important part of his arsenal in 2026, which contributed to the lowest walk rate (5.6%) of his career and his lowest opponent hard-hit rate since 2022.

    Quantrill's sinker and four-seamer each average roughly 94 miles per hour; the cutter is more like 89. When he needs to miss bats, a splitter that replaced his changeup in 2022 and took on more velocity separation from his fastballs this year does the job. Neither of Quantrill's breaking balls are very impressive, but he can show them enough to keep hitters honest, and he learned to land his curveball at the top of the zone to take advantage of hitters trying to be more patient in that area in the first season under ABS. All of those things fit what the Brewers like pitchers to do nicely; Chris Hook and Jim Henderson might even be able to unlock one more level of competence in him.

    Unlike several other hurlers still on the market, Quantrill probably won't land a multi-year deal. He's still in the prove-it phase, and might be in line for a contract similar to the one May signed with the Cardinals last winter, which paid him $12 million. If Milwaukee does ink Quantrill, it would probably be for a similar price. That's an amount they can easily afford, in light of the long-term windfall they'll realize after winning the Series. Quantrill should be easy to sell on the idea, not only because it would give him a chance to be part of a championship-caliber outfit, but because that might be the best way for him to get from where he is to the kind of money May just earned.

    From the Brewers' perspective, he'd only be a back-end rotation candidate. Misiorowski, Henderson, and Gasser all slot in ahead of him, and Priester and Harrison have more upside. For that matter, even Shane Drohan, Chad Patrick, DL Hall and Aaron Ashby might vie for a rotation spot alongside Quantrill. Still, great teams end up needing tons and tons of pitching, particularly as innings pile up due to repeated runs deep into October. The Brewers should consider making Quantrill one sponge for some of those innings; he might even turn out to be capable of taking the ball at the back end of a playoff rotation.


    Want to play the role of Brewers general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Brewers roster!

    Build Your 2027 Roster

    Follow Brewer Fanatic For Milwaukee Brewers News & Analysis

    Recent Brewers Articles

    Recent Brewers Videos

    Brewers Top Prospects

    Jett Williams

    Nashville Sounds - AAA, SS
    Despite a disappointing debut season in the Brewers organization (hit .233 in 81 games in Nashville, and .217 in 19 AFL games), Jett Williams w added to the team's 40-man roster today.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments

    Quantrill is interesting, but hes the exact kind of pitcher I dont want them to target. Quantrill will require enough money that he will be locked into a rotation spot, but likely mediocre enough that ill be upset hes pitching over someone in Nashville.

    If they can trade for an exciting playoff caliber starter, awsome, if not? They have alot of options for 3 spots, and would be better served adding 1 or 2 more that they arent married to.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...