Matthew Trueblood
Brewer Fanatic Editor-
Posts
2,071 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
10
Matthew Trueblood last won the day on February 28
Matthew Trueblood had the most liked content!
About Matthew Trueblood
- Birthday 03/31/1989
Recent Profile Visitors
The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.
Matthew Trueblood's Achievements
-
Matthew Trueblood started following Milwaukee Brewers Free-Agent Pitching Target: Cal Quantrill
-
Milwaukee Brewers Free-Agent Pitching Target: Cal Quantrill
Matthew Trueblood posted an article in Brewers
Although the Brewers believe in Kyle Harrison as a starter for 2027 and expect to get Quinn Priester back right away next spring, the team could use more starting pitching depth than they currently have in the organization. Maybe they'll bring back Brandon Woodruff—top executive Matt Arnold said Woodruff entered the offseason healthy and that he expects the veteran righthander to "be great next year"—but that's far from promised. At the moment, the team only has Jacob Misiorowski, Logan Henderson and Robert Gasser written into their 2027 rotation in pen; everyone else will have to prove their health and/or their capability. The need they face isn't acute enough to prompt them to behave unusually, though, and not just because they're still basking in the afterglow of winning the World Series. They circled back to talk with Dustin May after the righthander became a free agent, but they were not serious bidders for his services, a source close to May said. Nor are they likely to court even second-tier free-agent arms like Freddy Peralta, Trevor Rogers, or Michael King. They weren't involved in Sonny Gray's free agency before Gray signed with the Minnesota Twins Wednesday. They might not even go for the likes of Foster Griffin, Kaima Taira or Clay Holmes. One tier further down, though, some more plausible fits begin to show up. One pitcher who fits the Brewers to a 'T' is the resurgent Cal Quantrill, who cut his ERA in half and then some (from 6.04 in 2025 to 2.86) in 2026. Quantrill, 31, is the kind of starter the Brewers have often signed in past offseasons, and he would be an addition good enough to reinforce them for 2027 without interfering with any of their long-term plans. No team likes to lean on the fastball more than the Brewers, and Quantrill has become a three-fastballs guy who relies heavily on those offerings. For most pitchers, learning to throw all three fastballs means finding a sinker or a cutter, but those were the two heaters with which Quantrill was most comfortable for most of his career. It was the four-seamer that emerged as a far more important part of his arsenal in 2026, which contributed to the lowest walk rate (5.6%) of his career and his lowest opponent hard-hit rate since 2022. Quantrill's sinker and four-seamer each average roughly 94 miles per hour; the cutter is more like 89. When he needs to miss bats, a splitter that replaced his changeup in 2022 and took on more velocity separation from his fastballs this year does the job. Neither of Quantrill's breaking balls are very impressive, but he can show them enough to keep hitters honest, and he learned to land his curveball at the top of the zone to take advantage of hitters trying to be more patient in that area in the first season under ABS. All of those things fit what the Brewers like pitchers to do nicely; Chris Hook and Jim Henderson might even be able to unlock one more level of competence in him. Unlike several other hurlers still on the market, Quantrill probably won't land a multi-year deal. He's still in the prove-it phase, and might be in line for a contract similar to the one May signed with the Cardinals last winter, which paid him $12 million. If Milwaukee does ink Quantrill, it would probably be for a similar price. That's an amount they can easily afford, in light of the long-term windfall they'll realize after winning the Series. Quantrill should be easy to sell on the idea, not only because it would give him a chance to be part of a championship-caliber outfit, but because that might be the best way for him to get from where he is to the kind of money May just earned. From the Brewers' perspective, he'd only be a back-end rotation candidate. Misiorowski, Henderson, and Gasser all slot in ahead of him, and Priester and Harrison have more upside. For that matter, even Shane Drohan, Chad Patrick, DL Hall and Aaron Ashby might vie for a rotation spot alongside Quantrill. Still, great teams end up needing tons and tons of pitching, particularly as innings pile up due to repeated runs deep into October. The Brewers should consider making Quantrill one sponge for some of those innings; he might even turn out to be capable of taking the ball at the back end of a playoff rotation. -
Although the Brewers believe in Kyle Harrison as a starter for 2027 and expect to get Quinn Priester back right away next spring, the team could use more starting pitching depth than they currently have in the organization. Maybe they'll bring back Brandon Woodruff—top executive Matt Arnold said Woodruff entered the offseason healthy and that he expects the veteran righthander to "be great next year"—but that's far from promised. At the moment, the team only has Jacob Misiorowski, Logan Henderson and Robert Gasser written into their 2027 rotation in pen; everyone else will have to prove their health and/or their capability. The need they face isn't acute enough to prompt them to behave unusually, though, and not just because they're still basking in the afterglow of winning the World Series. They circled back to talk with Dustin May after the righthander became a free agent, but they were not serious bidders for his services, a source close to May said. Nor are they likely to court even second-tier free-agent arms like Freddy Peralta, Trevor Rogers, or Michael King. They weren't involved in Sonny Gray's free agency before Gray signed with the Minnesota Twins Wednesday. They might not even go for the likes of Foster Griffin, Kaima Taira or Clay Holmes. One tier further down, though, some more plausible fits begin to show up. One pitcher who fits the Brewers to a 'T' is the resurgent Cal Quantrill, who cut his ERA in half and then some (from 6.04 in 2025 to 2.86) in 2026. Quantrill, 31, is the kind of starter the Brewers have often signed in past offseasons, and he would be an addition good enough to reinforce them for 2027 without interfering with any of their long-term plans. No team likes to lean on the fastball more than the Brewers, and Quantrill has become a three-fastballs guy who relies heavily on those offerings. For most pitchers, learning to throw all three fastballs means finding a sinker or a cutter, but those were the two heaters with which Quantrill was most comfortable for most of his career. It was the four-seamer that emerged as a far more important part of his arsenal in 2026, which contributed to the lowest walk rate (5.6%) of his career and his lowest opponent hard-hit rate since 2022. Quantrill's sinker and four-seamer each average roughly 94 miles per hour; the cutter is more like 89. When he needs to miss bats, a splitter that replaced his changeup in 2022 and took on more velocity separation from his fastballs this year does the job. Neither of Quantrill's breaking balls are very impressive, but he can show them enough to keep hitters honest, and he learned to land his curveball at the top of the zone to take advantage of hitters trying to be more patient in that area in the first season under ABS. All of those things fit what the Brewers like pitchers to do nicely; Chris Hook and Jim Henderson might even be able to unlock one more level of competence in him. Unlike several other hurlers still on the market, Quantrill probably won't land a multi-year deal. He's still in the prove-it phase, and might be in line for a contract similar to the one May signed with the Cardinals last winter, which paid him $12 million. If Milwaukee does ink Quantrill, it would probably be for a similar price. That's an amount they can easily afford, in light of the long-term windfall they'll realize after winning the Series. Quantrill should be easy to sell on the idea, not only because it would give him a chance to be part of a championship-caliber outfit, but because that might be the best way for him to get from where he is to the kind of money May just earned. From the Brewers' perspective, he'd only be a back-end rotation candidate. Misiorowski, Henderson, and Gasser all slot in ahead of him, and Priester and Harrison have more upside. For that matter, even Shane Drohan, Chad Patrick, DL Hall and Aaron Ashby might vie for a rotation spot alongside Quantrill. Still, great teams end up needing tons and tons of pitching, particularly as innings pile up due to repeated runs deep into October. The Brewers should consider making Quantrill one sponge for some of those innings; he might even turn out to be capable of taking the ball at the back end of a playoff rotation. Image courtesy of Rick Scuteri-Imagn Images View full article
-
There was little doubt that the Brewers would add Jett Williams, Luke Adams and Cameron Wagoner to their 40-man roster Tuesday. All three players would have been eligible to be selected in the Rule 5 Draft if they hadn't been added, and although the coming lockout might cancel that draft, anyway, the team wasn't willing to risk losing those players. All three would have been strong candidates to be selected in that draft, had it happened and had they been left exposed to it. All three have plausible roles on the 2027 Brewers. As is often true with very deep organizations, though, Milwaukee also faced several closer calls ahead of Tuesday's deadline to protect players from the draft. They chose to add three more players whose likelihood of being picked was lower and whose long-term utility to the organization is less clear: catcher Matt Wood, second baseman Dylan O'Rae, and pitcher Tate Kuehner. That brought their 40-man list all the way to 40. It was a rare instance of a team with plenty of space on the roster suddenly filling it all. In light of those calls, it's increasingly clear that change is coming later this week. Milwaukee now has four catchers on its 40-man roster, in William Contreras, Bo Naylor, Jeferson Quero and Wood. The chances of a Contreras trade this winter are remote, but so are the chances that the team sticks with all four of those guys all winter. It's more likely that they'll either non-tender Naylor on Friday. or trade Quero at some point soon. That's one way they can either re-open a spot on the 40-man (for instance, for a free-agent addition later on) or shift their resources to have a more balanced group. Another player now on the chopping block was there all along, really. Tyler Black is almost certain to be waived or non-tendered and released outright this week. Though Adams (like Andrew Vaughn) bats right-handed and Black bats lefty, the Brewers have shown so little faith in the flash-in-the-pan former top prospect that it's almost impossible to imagine him lasting the winter on the 40-man list. He's out of options and can't be sent to the minors next spring without being offered to the other 29 teams, anyway. There are smaller chances of what would be bigger moves. Vaughn could be non-tendered, which might spare Black's roster spot. Trevor Megill (almost sure to be dealt sometime this winter) could be traded, opening a 40-man spot. However, the only moves with any real urgency to them are removing one of the catchers and disposing of Black. The Brewers' collection of optionable pitchers is one of the most enviable in the league. Megill is the only pitcher on the 40-man roster who can't be sent freely to the minors next year (though, in practice, several of them won't be). For that matter, the only position players in that predicament are Contreras, Christian Yelich, Vaughn and Black. For a World Series champion to have such roster flexibility is almost unheard of, but that's where the Brewers stand. They can, if they so choose, have a very quiet winter and still be a well-balanced, robust candidate to make another deep run into October next season.
- 17 comments
-
- 3
-
-
- jeferson quero
- bo naylor
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
There was little doubt that the Brewers would add Jett Williams, Luke Adams and Cameron Wagoner to their 40-man roster Tuesday. All three players would have been eligible to be selected in the Rule 5 Draft if they hadn't been added, and although the coming lockout might cancel that draft, anyway, the team wasn't willing to risk losing those players. All three would have been strong candidates to be selected in that draft, had it happened and had they been left exposed to it. All three have plausible roles on the 2027 Brewers. As is often true with very deep organizations, though, Milwaukee also faced several closer calls ahead of Tuesday's deadline to protect players from the draft. They chose to add three more players whose likelihood of being picked was lower and whose long-term utility to the organization is less clear: catcher Matt Wood, second baseman Dylan O'Rae, and pitcher Tate Kuehner. That brought their 40-man list all the way to 40. It was a rare instance of a team with plenty of space on the roster suddenly filling it all. In light of those calls, it's increasingly clear that change is coming later this week. Milwaukee now has four catchers on its 40-man roster, in William Contreras, Bo Naylor, Jeferson Quero and Wood. The chances of a Contreras trade this winter are remote, but so are the chances that the team sticks with all four of those guys all winter. It's more likely that they'll either non-tender Naylor on Friday. or trade Quero at some point soon. That's one way they can either re-open a spot on the 40-man (for instance, for a free-agent addition later on) or shift their resources to have a more balanced group. Another player now on the chopping block was there all along, really. Tyler Black is almost certain to be waived or non-tendered and released outright this week. Though Adams (like Andrew Vaughn) bats right-handed and Black bats lefty, the Brewers have shown so little faith in the flash-in-the-pan former top prospect that it's almost impossible to imagine him lasting the winter on the 40-man list. He's out of options and can't be sent to the minors next spring without being offered to the other 29 teams, anyway. There are smaller chances of what would be bigger moves. Vaughn could be non-tendered, which might spare Black's roster spot. Trevor Megill (almost sure to be dealt sometime this winter) could be traded, opening a 40-man spot. However, the only moves with any real urgency to them are removing one of the catchers and disposing of Black. The Brewers' collection of optionable pitchers is one of the most enviable in the league. Megill is the only pitcher on the 40-man roster who can't be sent freely to the minors next year (though, in practice, several of them won't be). For that matter, the only position players in that predicament are Contreras, Christian Yelich, Vaughn and Black. For a World Series champion to have such roster flexibility is almost unheard of, but that's where the Brewers stand. They can, if they so choose, have a very quiet winter and still be a well-balanced, robust candidate to make another deep run into October next season. Image courtesy of Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images View full article
- 17 replies
-
- jeferson quero
- bo naylor
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Hype hummed all around Jett Williams this spring in Arizona, but the diminutive utility man was inconsistent early in the Triple-A season and injured in the latter part of it. He drew positive reports as a third baseman, but at this point, it looks like he'll need to get comfortable and competent as a true rover: playing third base a few times a week, sliding over to second for occasional chances, and moonlighting in the outfield. He has to do all that and still become a more consistent offensive presence, which is no small task. The Brewers expressed a modicum of faith in him Tuesday afternoon, though, adding him to the 40-man roster to shield him from the Rule 5 Draft—even though that annual event will almost certainly be postponed and could well be canceled, as it was the last time the owners locked out the players over the offseason. Williams, 23, batted .233/.340/.384 in the minors this year, then .217/.379/.348 in the Arizona Fall League. His speed and athleticism are easy to see, but he didn't make the concrete progress for which the team hoped when they acquired him as half the return in the Freddy Peralta trade last winter. More to come, as we determine who else (if anyone) joined the 40-man roster ahead of Tuesday evening's deadline. UPDATE 5:00 PM CT: In addition to Williams, the Brewers added five more players to the 40-man Tuesday, the team announced. They include pitchers Tate Kuehner and Cameron Wagoner, plus first baseman Luke Adams and the speedy Dylan O'Rae, plus catcher Matt Wood. That brings their 40-man roster all the way to 40 players. Image courtesy of USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect View full article
-
Milwaukee Brewers Add Jett Williams, 5 Others to 40-Man Roster
Matthew Trueblood posted an article in Brewers
Hype hummed all around Jett Williams this spring in Arizona, but the diminutive utility man was inconsistent early in the Triple-A season and injured in the latter part of it. He drew positive reports as a third baseman, but at this point, it looks like he'll need to get comfortable and competent as a true rover: playing third base a few times a week, sliding over to second for occasional chances, and moonlighting in the outfield. He has to do all that and still become a more consistent offensive presence, which is no small task. The Brewers expressed a modicum of faith in him Tuesday afternoon, though, adding him to the 40-man roster to shield him from the Rule 5 Draft—even though that annual event will almost certainly be postponed and could well be canceled, as it was the last time the owners locked out the players over the offseason. Williams, 23, batted .233/.340/.384 in the minors this year, then .217/.379/.348 in the Arizona Fall League. His speed and athleticism are easy to see, but he didn't make the concrete progress for which the team hoped when they acquired him as half the return in the Freddy Peralta trade last winter. More to come, as we determine who else (if anyone) joined the 40-man roster ahead of Tuesday evening's deadline. UPDATE 5:00 PM CT: In addition to Williams, the Brewers added five more players to the 40-man Tuesday, the team announced. They include pitchers Tate Kuehner and Cameron Wagoner, plus first baseman Luke Adams and the speedy Dylan O'Rae, plus catcher Matt Wood. That brings their 40-man roster all the way to 40 players. -
The Milwaukee Brewers acquired right-handed reliever Ryan Walker from the San Francisco Giants for minor-league pitchers Blake Holub and Gavin Perry, the team announced Sunday evening. Walker, who will turn 31 later this month, has a 3.56 career ERA and 31 saves over parts of four seasons with the Giants, but an ugly 7.16 ERA paved a path out of town for him in 2026. This is one of several moves likely to happen throughout the league over the next 48 hours, as teams both gear up for the looming lockout and respond to the onrushing deadline to protect players from the Rule 5 Draft by placing them on the 40-man roster. Holub, whom the Brewers acquired from the Tigers in November 2023 when they traded Mark Canha to Detroit, is eligible for the Rule 5 Draft if not rostered this week, and it was unlikely the Brewers were going to protect him. The Giants will take a flier on him, but they also got value from this deal in the form of Perry, whom the Brewers picked in the 11th round this July and who has yet to throw a professional pitch. Milwaukee gave him the full $150,000 signing bonus he could receive without counting against the team's draft bonus pool. Walker is arbitration-eligible for the first time this winter. Given how poorly his 2026 campaign went, the Giants felt his 40-man roster spot was better spent on (presumably) Holub, and they'll avoid having to pay any more than the league minimum to him. For the Brewers, however, the upside is obvious. Walker has a mid-90s sinker with extremely heavy action and a sweeper that helped him rack up big strikeout rates in his first two big-league seasons. That pitch has been less effective and induced fewer whiffs over the last two campaigns, but the Crew are willing to bet on their pitching development group to turn him around. With a low arm slot and a crossfire delivery, Walker can be very deceptive and is tough on right-handed batters, but he'll need better ways to get out lefties; they had a 1.052 OPS against him in limited 2026 action. The problems Walker faces aren't dissimilar to those that threatened the viability of Grant Anderson when the Brewers proactively scooped him up in a trade with the Rangers three years ago. As was true with Anderson, though, Walker can be optioned to the minor leagues, so this deal gives them roster flexibility, as well as a potential boost in high-leverage spots if he does turn a corner. Since Holub was a candidate to be selected in the Rule 5, anyway, this is a very low-cost acquisition of a player with clear big-league bona fides. The challenge before Chris Hook and Jim Henderson is clear: figure out how to get some platoon balance into the profile, and get him back to missing bats. If they can do that, the Brewers will have another sneaky trade win on their hands. Image courtesy of Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images View full article
- 9 replies
-
- ryan walker
- blake holub
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
The Milwaukee Brewers acquired right-handed reliever Ryan Walker from the San Francisco Giants for minor-league pitchers Blake Holub and Gavin Perry, the team announced Sunday evening. Walker, who will turn 31 later this month, has a 3.56 career ERA and 31 saves over parts of four seasons with the Giants, but an ugly 7.16 ERA paved a path out of town for him in 2026. This is one of several moves likely to happen throughout the league over the next 48 hours, as teams both gear up for the looming lockout and respond to the onrushing deadline to protect players from the Rule 5 Draft by placing them on the 40-man roster. Holub, whom the Brewers acquired from the Tigers in November 2023 when they traded Mark Canha to Detroit, is eligible for the Rule 5 Draft if not rostered this week, and it was unlikely the Brewers were going to protect him. The Giants will take a flier on him, but they also got value from this deal in the form of Perry, whom the Brewers picked in the 11th round this July and who has yet to throw a professional pitch. Milwaukee gave him the full $150,000 signing bonus he could receive without counting against the team's draft bonus pool. Walker is arbitration-eligible for the first time this winter. Given how poorly his 2026 campaign went, the Giants felt his 40-man roster spot was better spent on (presumably) Holub, and they'll avoid having to pay any more than the league minimum to him. For the Brewers, however, the upside is obvious. Walker has a mid-90s sinker with extremely heavy action and a sweeper that helped him rack up big strikeout rates in his first two big-league seasons. That pitch has been less effective and induced fewer whiffs over the last two campaigns, but the Crew are willing to bet on their pitching development group to turn him around. With a low arm slot and a crossfire delivery, Walker can be very deceptive and is tough on right-handed batters, but he'll need better ways to get out lefties; they had a 1.052 OPS against him in limited 2026 action. The problems Walker faces aren't dissimilar to those that threatened the viability of Grant Anderson when the Brewers proactively scooped him up in a trade with the Rangers three years ago. As was true with Anderson, though, Walker can be optioned to the minor leagues, so this deal gives them roster flexibility, as well as a potential boost in high-leverage spots if he does turn a corner. Since Holub was a candidate to be selected in the Rule 5, anyway, this is a very low-cost acquisition of a player with clear big-league bona fides. The challenge before Chris Hook and Jim Henderson is clear: figure out how to get some platoon balance into the profile, and get him back to missing bats. If they can do that, the Brewers will have another sneaky trade win on their hands.
- 9 comments
-
- 2
-
-
-
- ryan walker
- blake holub
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
No one is arguing, exactly, that small ball isn't valuable. All the little things that broadcasters with World Series rings from the 1990s talk about relentlessly do matter; they do help a team score runs. We count sacrifice bunts, sacrifice flies, times hit by pitch, stolen bases and more because they each represent advancement toward scoring, and they can be accomplished without truly winning the battle at the plate. The majority of the time, as the batter, you lose the battle, so it's important to be able to do positive things without winning the battle, at times. Small ball is brittle, though, because you have to do several of them in just the right sequence to create a run. It's very hard, in particular, to score multiple runs in an inning or four or five runs in a game using small ball. Certainly, no one is arguing that the long ball isn't valuable. Hitting a home run is easily the best thing a batter can do. Its only vice is its obviousness; there's no question about whether hitting homers drives scoring. Every year, more than a third of the runs scored in the majors come home when the ball is hit over the fence. You need to hit homers sometimes to maintain a strong offense. Home runs are a brittle source of value, too, though, because unless the pitcher you're facing has extremely underwhelming stuff or makes a mistake or two, it's hard to hit them. Going to the plate with the plan of hitting a homer can lead to bad swing decisions and a lot of easy outs. The constant debate is over whether small ball or the long ball is more important. Most fans have a preferred style, and they champion it relentlessly. The reality is that most games are won by the less brittle things that fall in between a couple hundred huge plays and a couple hundred tiny ones. Most at-bats end in something other than small ball or the long ball. A team can more reliably excel in those wide swaths of encounters, where the skill of the game reveals itself in tiny dribs and drabs. The 2026 Brewers were that kind of team. They won games with ruthless medium ball. If you add up each team's sacrifice bunts and flies, their times hit by pitch and their stolen bases and you subtract their times grounding into double plays or being caught stealing, the Brewers don't come out as the leaders. It's not even especially close. Milwaukee was eighth in baseball with 131 net positive events from small ball, but the Marlins and Nationals each had more than 175. The White Sox, Guardians, Red Sox, Rays and Padres all played small ball better than the Brewers. You surely heard this enough times during October not to need it said, but the team also finished tied for 28th in home runs, at 154. Only the Blue Jays hit fewer dingers, and nine teams hit at least 50 more. Were the Brewers remotely dependent on either small ball or the long ball, they'd have ended up with a league-average offense, or worse. But what about medium ball? If you simply add walks, singles, doubles and triples for each team, the Brewers come out first for 2026—and it's not close. They had 1,952 of those positive events, and their ratio of positive events in all plate appearances that didn't end in either small ball outcomes or the long ball was the highest in the league. The Yankees and Reds had fewer than 1,600 medium-ball contributions. Nineteen of the 30 teams had fewer than 1,700. The Brewers didn't lean on small ball, really. They certainly didn't hit a special number of long balls. On all the plays that didn't fall into either of those buckets, though, their superiority over the rest of the league shined through. That made room for the lethal sequences in which they seemed to eviscerate an opponent by running a carousel on the bases, as they did against the Padres in the bottom of the ninth inning in NLDS Game 2 and in the top of the fifth against the Rays in World Series Game 3. It also allowed them to score in shorter sequences than a true small-ball team, though. The signature hit of this team was the RBI double with a runner on first. They had 67 such hits in the regular season, eight more than any other team, and four more in October. When William Contreras drove home the penultimate run of the champions' season with a double to the left-field wall in World Series Game 5, Christian Yelich scored all the way from first base. He'd reached via hit by pitch. He scored because he's fast and read the play well. There was small ball in it, but that wasn't a small ball play. It was medium ball, and while that sounds less than heroic, it was the way the 2026 Brewers set themselves apart. They could score fast or slow, but they were harder to stop than a team selling out for power or one that wanted to dink and dunk you to death. They struck a balance rare even among the best teams in the league each year. The debate will continue among the less learned, but those who watched closely know that small ball vs. the long ball is a false dichotomy. The best team in baseball found a happy medium this year. Image courtesy of USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect View full article
-
No one is arguing, exactly, that small ball isn't valuable. All the little things that broadcasters with World Series rings from the 1990s talk about relentlessly do matter; they do help a team score runs. We count sacrifice bunts, sacrifice flies, times hit by pitch, stolen bases and more because they each represent advancement toward scoring, and they can be accomplished without truly winning the battle at the plate. The majority of the time, as the batter, you lose the battle, so it's important to be able to do positive things without winning the battle, at times. Small ball is brittle, though, because you have to do several of them in just the right sequence to create a run. It's very hard, in particular, to score multiple runs in an inning or four or five runs in a game using small ball. Certainly, no one is arguing that the long ball isn't valuable. Hitting a home run is easily the best thing a batter can do. Its only vice is its obviousness; there's no question about whether hitting homers drives scoring. Every year, more than a third of the runs scored in the majors come home when the ball is hit over the fence. You need to hit homers sometimes to maintain a strong offense. Home runs are a brittle source of value, too, though, because unless the pitcher you're facing has extremely underwhelming stuff or makes a mistake or two, it's hard to hit them. Going to the plate with the plan of hitting a homer can lead to bad swing decisions and a lot of easy outs. The constant debate is over whether small ball or the long ball is more important. Most fans have a preferred style, and they champion it relentlessly. The reality is that most games are won by the less brittle things that fall in between a couple hundred huge plays and a couple hundred tiny ones. Most at-bats end in something other than small ball or the long ball. A team can more reliably excel in those wide swaths of encounters, where the skill of the game reveals itself in tiny dribs and drabs. The 2026 Brewers were that kind of team. They won games with ruthless medium ball. If you add up each team's sacrifice bunts and flies, their times hit by pitch and their stolen bases and you subtract their times grounding into double plays or being caught stealing, the Brewers don't come out as the leaders. It's not even especially close. Milwaukee was eighth in baseball with 131 net positive events from small ball, but the Marlins and Nationals each had more than 175. The White Sox, Guardians, Red Sox, Rays and Padres all played small ball better than the Brewers. You surely heard this enough times during October not to need it said, but the team also finished tied for 28th in home runs, at 154. Only the Blue Jays hit fewer dingers, and nine teams hit at least 50 more. Were the Brewers remotely dependent on either small ball or the long ball, they'd have ended up with a league-average offense, or worse. But what about medium ball? If you simply add walks, singles, doubles and triples for each team, the Brewers come out first for 2026—and it's not close. They had 1,952 of those positive events, and their ratio of positive events in all plate appearances that didn't end in either small ball outcomes or the long ball was the highest in the league. The Yankees and Reds had fewer than 1,600 medium-ball contributions. Nineteen of the 30 teams had fewer than 1,700. The Brewers didn't lean on small ball, really. They certainly didn't hit a special number of long balls. On all the plays that didn't fall into either of those buckets, though, their superiority over the rest of the league shined through. That made room for the lethal sequences in which they seemed to eviscerate an opponent by running a carousel on the bases, as they did against the Padres in the bottom of the ninth inning in NLDS Game 2 and in the top of the fifth against the Rays in World Series Game 3. It also allowed them to score in shorter sequences than a true small-ball team, though. The signature hit of this team was the RBI double with a runner on first. They had 67 such hits in the regular season, eight more than any other team, and four more in October. When William Contreras drove home the penultimate run of the champions' season with a double to the left-field wall in World Series Game 5, Christian Yelich scored all the way from first base. He'd reached via hit by pitch. He scored because he's fast and read the play well. There was small ball in it, but that wasn't a small ball play. It was medium ball, and while that sounds less than heroic, it was the way the 2026 Brewers set themselves apart. They could score fast or slow, but they were harder to stop than a team selling out for power or one that wanted to dink and dunk you to death. They struck a balance rare even among the best teams in the league each year. The debate will continue among the less learned, but those who watched closely know that small ball vs. the long ball is a false dichotomy. The best team in baseball found a happy medium this year.
-
Not picking on any one take, just grabbing this one because it's the clearest distillation of something I've seen many people say: I do not believe this is true. I think Made could come up next May even without an extension; I think he could debut in September even with one. I think a very limited sample has distorted some folks' idea of how much each extension is achieved by the Brewers applying the threat of more time in the minors as leverage. It's a factor, but not the driving or even an especially prominent one. I don't think there's much chance *at all* that a healthy Made's debut is pushed off to 2028, as multiple people have suggested, unless he goes backward developmentally. I definitely don't think his arrival in the bigs is contingent on an extension. That's not how they approach those conversations, even among themselves in the FO. They'll call him up when he's ready. Only when it's a coin-toss call does whether the player is amenable to a long-term deal become an important consideration.
- 18 replies
-
- jesus made
- joey ortiz
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
In the first major position-player signing of the winter, the World Series champion Brewers lost their leading home run hitter. Jake Bauers and the Boston Red Sox agreed on a four-year, $58-million deal Friday, a source confirmed to Brewer Fanatic. Jeff Passan of ESPN broke the news on Twitter. Bauers, 31, cashes in after a late breakout season. He batted .266/.389/.484 in 578 plate appearances, then put together two of the best at-bats in Brewers history during a heroic NLCS showing. Losing him is bad news for the team on two fronts, as they must do without their best pure power hitter from this season and his exceptionally positive clubhouse influence. As compensation (if small consolation), they'll receive a draft pick immediately after the end of the first round of the 2027 MLB Draft. Because they had extended Bauers the qualifying offer (and he signed for more than $50 million in guaranteed money), they get a chance to infuse their robust farm system with more talent and soften the blow of being last in the usual draft order after winning it all. Milwaukee executive Matt Arnold sounded resigned to this outcome when he spoke about Bauers at this week's GM Meetings in Las Vegas. "Yeah, obviously you have the conversations when you extend that, so he knows we'd love to have him back," Arnold said, when asked whether the team had renewed contact with the free agent since making the QO earlier this month. "He’s a free agent, obviously, allowed to talk to whoever he wants, but he meant a lot to our franchise, for sure." That Arnold put Bauers's time with the Crew in the past tense before there was any report that he was on the verge of signing said it all. The team was interested in a reunion, but only on terms they knew he was unlikely to accept. He loved his time in Milwaukee, and the player, his teammates and the fan base will be forever intertwined. However, the Brewers make these types of decisions without letting sentiment drive them, which made Bauers departing a virtual certainty. The team will have to replace Bauers's exceptional production, especially against right-handed pitchers, and they're likely to spend something this winter to bolster their positional corps. They feel good about their remaining incumbent at first base, Andrew Vaughn, but a trade (or even a non-tender) of the expensive Vaughn is possible in the coming days. Pat Murphy is effusive in his praise of Vaughn's willingness to accept feedback and play in whatever role is asked of him, and that role could now expand next year. "Yeah, he's a really good player and certainly talented and contributed, you know, beyond our expectations," Arnold said of Vaughn. "I mean, he just, he came in and did a fantastic job for us. Murph is right about him being the right kind of guy, and certainly talented and a guy that meant a lot to our team. So, yeah, I think he's a really important part of this." However, Vaughn is a clear downgrade from Bauers. The Brewers get a premium draft pick for losing their main first baseman, but the day is (at best) bittersweet. One of the best stories and teammates on a championship team, Bauers will now bring those good things to a bigger-market environment. Image courtesy of Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images View full article

