Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
  • Brewers News & Analysis

    The Brewers Have Two Paths Forward at First Base, and Only One Features Andrew Vaughn

    Andrew Vaughn could assume a bigger role in 2027 as Jake Bauers's replacement, but he could just as easily be out of Milwaukee entirely.

    Jack Stern
    Image courtesy of Benny Sieu-Imagn Images

    Brewers Video

    In the long run, the Brewers should be fine without Jake Bauers, after their NLCS MVP found a deserved payday in Boston. Their deep farm system boasts plenty of first basemen, including Southern League MVP Blake Burke and minor-league home run leader Andrew Fischer. The Brewers also selected corner infielder Luke Adams to the 40-man roster earlier this week to protect him from a potential Rule 5 draft.

    In the short term, though, there’s no enviable left-handed-hitting starter at first base. Burke looked overmatched by Triple-A pitching after a late-season promotion and may need more seasoning. Fischer’s excellent swing decisions and prodigious power were paired with one of the highest in-zone whiff rates in professional baseball. Tyler Black is out of minor-league options, and he’s not guaranteed to survive the winter on the 40-man roster. Black played left field most of the time in Nashville this year after failing to acclimate to first base, and the bat control that once made up for his lack of power has regressed over the last two seasons.

    The free agent market isn’t much better. Among left-handed first basemen, Nathaniel Lowe is the best fit on a modest one-year deal. After that, the veterans with sound swing decisions are LaMonte Wade Jr. and Pavin Smith, who combined for a 72 OPS+ in 2026. The Brewers could take a flier on either to bounce back as a productive platoon bat, but they would essentially be paying for an older and slower version of Black.

    Andrew Vaughn is the most experienced and simplest in-house replacement, and how the Brewers proceed depends on whether they view him as a full-time player. For his career, Vaughn has mashed against left-handed pitching (127 wRC+) but been inconsistent against right-handers (97 wRC+). His 117 wRC+ against righties this year was a career best, but it came in just 198 plate appearances, as the Brewers shielded him from sinker-sweeper righties.

    MLB Trade Rumors’s arbitration model projects Vaughn at an $8.5-million salary in 2027, his final season before free agency. That’s a hefty price for the short side of a first-base platoon, and even if the Brewers have more payroll flexibility after their World Series win, they won’t stray from their cost-effective process. If they don’t view Vaughn as close to a full-time player, they might trade him (or, if teams don’t bite at his salary, non-tender him on Friday afternoon).

    While Vaughn was highly productive in his limited role, he did not improve against righties who pitched him horizontally. Vaughn managed just a .255 wOBA and .283 xwOBA against right-handed sinkers and sweepers, worse than his career marks. Even in favorable matchups, he enjoyed some good luck and wasn’t quite as dangerous as his results suggest. The gap between Vaughn’s .368 wOBA and .329 xwOBA made him one of baseball’s top overperformers, and his 110 DRC+ lagged behind his 134 wRC+.

    The right-handed hitting Adams is a viable replacement. Big-league pitchers could exploit his patient approach without some adjustments, but his sound plate discipline and improving hit tool mean he could match or exceed Vaughn’s production in a part-time role next year. ZiPS projects a higher OPS+ for Adams (115) than Vaughn (103), including a higher slugging percentage against lefties. Burke and Adams forming a productive platoon by the second half wouldn’t be surprising.

    On the other hand, the 28-year-old Vaughn is more mature than the hitter who struggled against certain righties early in his career. He became far more disciplined after joining the Brewers last summer and maintained that lower chase rate against righties this year.

    vaughn_rhp_chase(1).jpeg

    Even if east-west sequences still pose a challenge, there’s an argument that a healthy Vaughn with improved plate discipline could prove perfectly productive in same-side matchups. He slashed his chase rate against righty sinkers to a career-best 25% this year, and after his bat speed against righties dipped upon his return from a fractured hamate, it bounced back in the second half.

    vaughn_rhp_bat_speed.jpeg

    If Vaughn returns to start most games, the Brewers could get more creative in finding a left-handed backup until Burke or another prospect debuts. Wade Jr. or Smith would be better fits than Black as bench bats who can be released midseason if necessary. Christian Yelich was a first baseman in high school and began taking pregame reps there this year.

    Friday’s tender deadline might not be a hard decision point, but with a lockout looming at the start of December, the Brewers’ succession plan after Bauers should become clear soon. They’ll either give Vaughn starting duties or overhaul the position.


    Want to play the role of Brewers general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Brewers roster!

    Build Your 2027 Roster

    Follow Brewer Fanatic For Milwaukee Brewers News & Analysis

    Recent Brewers Articles

    Recent Brewers Videos

    Brewers Top Prospects

    Jett Williams

    Nashville Sounds - AAA, SS
    Despite a disappointing debut season in the Brewers organization (hit .233 in 81 games in Nashville, and .217 in 19 AFL games), Jett Williams w added to the team's 40-man roster today.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...