I'm also in the trade Fielder camp. Sure, he won't bring as much as he would have last year, but his value could drop much, much further, and there are very few left who believe he has any long-term future with this organization. Then either bring in a cheap, stopgap (Hatteberg-type) 1B either as part of the trade or as a FA, as well as Branyan. Let the following battle it out in spring: For 1B: Nelson/Stopgap/Branyan. If you're feeling crazy, maybe even let Mike Rivera in as a platoon candidate For 3B: Hall/Branyan/Gamel/ I'm not opposed to trading Hall if we get a decent offer, but I don't think we're going to get a decent offer. I'm more willing than most to give Weeks at least another half season at 2B, although signing Hudson is intriguing. Hardy stays at SS, Escobar gets a full year in AAA. Speculating beyond 2009 is a tough task, but in the spirit of wild speculation I'd say Hardy gets traded in the 09/10 offseason to make room for Escobar, Gamel gets an full year to prove he can play 3rd, shows he can't, and then moves to 1st, Weeks somehow continues to hold 2nd, and 3rd is manned by some random FA after Gamel moves. Brent Brewer replaces replaces the random FA in mid 2011 and puts up the best career numbers of any Zduriencik-drafted infielder.