The Brewers could commit to that deal for Naylor. But why is that the best use of resources for the Brewers? A 120ish wRC+ 1B does not move the needle for this offense. They could run it back with a Vaughn/Bauers platoon and get similar production
Meanwhile we just witnessed a playoff run where the Brewers basically had one guy they were comfortable starting against any lineup. The Brewers obviously do a great job developing pitching, but playoff starters are a scarce commodity and Woodruff is one of them when healthy. It’s well worth the risk attached to it