Personally I feel that a handshake is all that is needed to get the ball back. To the HY, the ball is just another item/collectible, but to Coghlan it is something that is very personal. While professionals are not perfect, they put in a lot of time and effort to get to where they are...I think its only fair to let them have the ball as a mile marker for their career. As for ball hawking in general, to each his own. I personally don't understand it, but if its not hurting anyone, then whatever. I think its more the HY interactions with the Marlins that have him in the wrong here, not necessarily his ball hawking habit.