I guess everyone has a different definition of average, but Wisconsin has been performing at a pretty casual level you expect out of most teams in the P5. 4/7 years they have made the dance, no higher than a 5 seed, can't make the Sweet 16, and have been ranked 14+ on three occasions in that span to end the year. I believe they have two Big Ten titles in that span, but both were shared...one of which was a 3-way tie.
I mean, if you want to call that slightly above average, sure, I guess. It is certainly a sharp decline from what they had seen prior to Gard taking over. I guess it is a matter of what you think Wisconsin's ceiling can be in the NIL era.