I would guess Bucksman and Brett's definition of what constitutes hitting is different. I value on base percentage a lot but I don't consider it hitting. I consider it a part of the total offensive ability of the player. When I think hitting I think of putting wood on the ball and it falling in for a non-out. Personally I think I would rather put Hardy in because of his ability to put wood on the ball more consistently (not necessarily non-outs) and his (my own preception) ability to judge balls and strikes. Granted there are no statistical facts to back me up yet on that assumption. Billy Hall on the other hand I feel falls prey to a Roger Clemens type pitcher. Smart, hits his spots, and can strike guys out. I hope Billy proves me wrong tonight.