I've seen a few car repair threads here and have seen people get good advice, so I thought I'd give it a shot. I had my 2001 Dodge Stratus with 190,000 miles break down a few weeks back. The repair shop (a reputable one for what it's worth) says that the timing belt snapped and maybe the water pump but he can't be sure about the pump until he starts the work. The car has always treated us well and has brand new brakes and we were really hoping to get another year out of it so we can finish paying off our other car before we take on another car payment. The repair guy, however, is really trying to talk me out of fixing it. Crazy. He says I'm looking at anywhere from $5-800 in repairs, depending on the water pump. He seems to think the head gasket will go soon (and then that's a big money repair), but when pressed on the head gasket he doesn't say why, other than saying 200,000 miles is a lot of miles on a Stratus. If he has a real concrete reason on why he thinks the head gasket is about to go, he's not saying or he just isn't good at communicating it. It's almost bewildering how hard he's trying to talk me out of fixing the car, but he just isn't making a convincing argument. Am I crazy to spend the money on the car? Or is it a good gamble seeing as we can pay off our other car in less than a year if we don't take on another car payment? I'd usually just say "fix it" but his hesitation is really making me double guess my judgement.