Take a look at Brewerfan Political Scene. The whole place is people insulting each other. This forum has lasted a LONG time in large part because of moderation to avoid politics. If one wants Brewerfan to be every other place on the internet and allow it all, you'll get just that, just as you'll get more trolls, more low-quality posts and members coming and going. Brewerfan is very unique in that many of us are older and many of us have been posting for a decade+.
>There have been times in the past when we lift the veil because "enough is enough"
How have those times been received, though? For every Schwartz there's an equal and opposite Schwartz. Like the Roe v. Wade banner which was put up when the site first turned over certainly was considered by some to be one of those times, but others not so much (that was as neutral as I could get it).
I've been an active poster on this site for 20 years and if we allowed politics I'd leave. This is the only friendly place on the internet I know of, but I know just what would happen if we started allowing it.