I think Counsell needs to just set a lineup of Cain, Yelich, Aguliar, Shaw, Braun, Moose, Schoop, Pina Then switch out Pina and Kratz every 3 games or so. Arcia comes in 7th or later for defense. Go offense at first because Schoop and Shaw havent been a disaster up the middle.. Against lefties I can see swapping out Shaw for Perez or Schoop . But no more screwing around against righties.