Small market teams can’t afford to just take large money risks whenever they get the itch, because if it fail’s they don’t have the ability to just pony up for another roll of the dice. And to use “butwhatif” hypotheticals is just silly. But you do it because thats all you have. You don’t give a real blueprint to success, offer any “big money” moves that you know absolutely wins them a World Series. Just hypotheticals so you can complain about the team not doing it the way you would…even though you don’t even know how you would or could do it better.
As for this move, it seems pretty obvious why it would be done and how it makes the team better now. Get immediate LH relief help for a guy 5-6yrs away (assuming he makes it to the big leagues at all). Moves like this are how the Brewers built an extremely good bullpen, while not paying relievers $6-$10 million a year, which simply doesn’t fit this teams philosophy of budget construction. But paying that money to a reliever that doesn’t pan out absolutely keeps them from making other aggressive moves…like signing a Yelich or Churio type contract. It’s like you want them to play poker just stupidly making every call no matter the cards they’re dealt. That’s a sure fire way to lose far more than you win. And if you haven’t noticed, the Brewers have done the exact opposite the past decade. Maybe you should find a new team to “root” for.