Murph is elite at motivating and creating a strong culture. No arguing that. But I think that aspect clouds his judgment too much. The leash is always too long when relievers are struggling. Ashby has been bad for a month now but he stands by his guys. Batting Yeli's corpse leadoff is indefensible. But he loves Yeli.
He'll ignore numbers for gut feel in those instances, but then pinch hit Bauers in the ninth because of the numbers. It's so frustrating.