Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted
7 minutes ago, homer said:

I think it's was a fumble but I am surprised they didn't even show a replay

His shin also looked to be down before the ball came out.  Weird they didn’t even look at it.

Posted

🤣

If Eichorst wants to hire "his guy," and does not have his hands tied by the buyout, I think there is a good chance that Fickell is fired tomorrow.

Posted
1 minute ago, JosephC said:

🤣

If Eichorst wants to hire "his guy," and does not have his hands tied by the buyout, I think there is a good chance that Fickell is fired tomorrow.

I'm guessing there's going to be some communication almost immediately with some of the big dollar donors.

Posted

So Fickells buyout is currently 21.3 million and it drops to 19.2 million after the season.

I say for that price difference just hand him his pink slip and get started looking for the next guy.

Extending him after last season should be a criminal offense.

Posted
28 minutes ago, yourout said:

Lots of freshman mistakes today.

Five fumbles, three credited to Hopkins.  I think at least four if not every one of those fumbles was on their half of the field.  

Not sure what the play call was, but Dupree should have picked up the blitz. Blitzer was outside the tackle with the DE/EDGE over or on the tackle's outside shoulder. Tackle was engaged with the DE/EDGE, too far out for the guard to slide over.  Dupree has to see that, or Hopkins has to see that and call it out, so that Dupree doesn't sprint out on the fake screen.

They actually ran the ball somewhat effectively in the first half, but then for some reason abandoned the run in the second half.  Sama had two carries for 20 yards.  Don't know if he got injured, but only two carries?

Grimes is just not a Big Ten coordinator.

  • Like 2
Posted
2 minutes ago, LouisEly said:

Five fumbles, three credited to Hopkins.  I think at least four if not every one of those fumbles was on their half of the field.  

Not sure what the play call was, but Dupree should have picked up the blitz. Blitzer was outside the tackle with the DE/EDGE over or on the tackle's outside shoulder. Tackle was engaged with the DE/EDGE, too far out for the guard to slide over.  Dupree has to see that, or Hopkins has to see that and call it out, so that Dupree doesn't sprint out on the fake screen.

They actually ran the ball somewhat effectively in the first half, but then for some reason abandoned the run in the second half.  Sama had two carries for 20 yards.  Don't know if he got injured, but only two carries?

Grimes is just not a Big Ten coordinator.

I think that play in particular falls on the quarterback for not recognizing and changing up the blocking or the play call.

Posted

It was a very strange day for the defense. The offense & kicking game did little to nothing AFA helping them out field position-wise, and if not for the miscues they probably don't give up 24 points. OTOH, the University of Maryland sends their backup QB out there & he throws........two incompletions all day? A lot of their big plays made in the 2nd half were due to taking advantage of poor down & distance due to MD being a really undisciplined team. This was a day to take advantage of the backup, turn him over 3 or 4 times & help out a kid making his first ever road start. Never happened. By the last FG drive it sort of looked like they cried uncle, and it's hard to blame them.

The other thing that would've helped Hopkins out today would've been to not constantly leave him in 2nd & ten. You can't win in someone else's house if you can't get a push btwn the tackles on 1st down, and short passes in the flat to a RB right at the line of scrimmage---I call those "Longos"---won't suffice. Kawecki has moved to guard since returning with Blackmon staying at C, but I don't see any appreciable difference. I'm sure they miss Haywood. I actually thought they were close to being home free when, on the next-to-last possession up seven, they ran on 1st down & gained five yards. But that was it. Move the chains there, you probably take it to 2 minutes or drain their TOs---or both. And if you eventually punt it puts them much further back.

The worst thing is losing to a team that had momentum after winning at Purdue but then came out & constantly shot themselves in the foot. As for Fickell, it's anyone's coin flip but I'd guess he comes back next year only if he wins out, including the bowl game. But Minnesota has a pretty physical front seven & I have to squint pretty hard to see this O-line establishing anything vs them. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Jim French Stepstool said:

It was a very strange day for the defense. The offense & kicking game did little to nothing AFA helping them out field position-wise, and if not for the miscues they probably don't give up 24 points. OTOH, the University of Maryland sends their backup QB out there & he throws........two incompletions all day? A lot of their big plays made in the 2nd half were due to taking advantage of poor down & distance due to MD being a really undisciplined team. This was a day to take advantage of the backup, turn him over 3 or 4 times & help out a kid making his first ever road start. Never happened. By the last FG drive it sort of looked like they cried uncle, and it's hard to blame them.

The other thing that would've helped Hopkins out today would've been to not constantly leave him in 2nd & ten. You can't win by going into another house & not being able to get a push btwn the tackles on 1st & 10. Kawecki has moved to guard since returning with Blackmon staying at C, but I don't see any appreciable difference. I'm sure they miss Haywood. I actually thought they were close to being home free when, on the next-to-last possession up seven, they ran on 1st down & gained five yards. But that was it. Move the chains there, you probably take it to 2 minutes or drain their TOs---or both. And if you eventually punt it puts them much further back.

The worst thing is losing to a team that had momentum after winning at Purdue but then came out & constantly shot themselves in the foot. As for Fickell, it's anyone's coin flip but I'd guess he comes back next year only if he wins out, including the bowl game. But Minnesota has a pretty physical front seven & I have to squint pretty hard to see this O-line establishing anything vs them. 

As usual, I did not watch the game, but your analysis is pretty much spot on what is being said on all the podcasts.  Defense not nearly aggressive enough against a backup quarterback, laid back too much early and pretty much let him get in a comfort zone.  Running game suffers and the OL has been getting undue credit for being better when it still cannot be considered even an average Big 10 line.  Haywood may have been an upgrade, but frankly he hasn't lived up to his recruiting hype and isn't very good either.  After being humiliated at home by Maryland last year that resulted in the Fire Fickell chants, the coaches should have been on them all week and had them up for this game and yet they go in and lay an egg against an inferior team playing under an interim head coach and with a backup QB.

  • Like 1
Posted
44 minutes ago, LouisEly said:

Five fumbles, three credited to Hopkins.  I think at least four if not every one of those fumbles was on their half of the field.  

Not sure what the play call was, but Dupree should have picked up the blitz. Blitzer was outside the tackle with the DE/EDGE over or on the tackle's outside shoulder. Tackle was engaged with the DE/EDGE, too far out for the guard to slide over.  Dupree has to see that, or Hopkins has to see that and call it out, so that Dupree doesn't sprint out on the fake screen.

They actually ran the ball somewhat effectively in the first half, but then for some reason abandoned the run in the second half.  Sama had two carries for 20 yards.  Don't know if he got injured, but only two carries?

Grimes is just not a Big Ten coordinator.

And Fickell isn't a Big Ten head coach.

  • Like 1
Posted
33 minutes ago, JosephC said:

  Running game suffers and the OL has been getting undue credit for being better when it still cannot be considered even an average Big 10 line.  Haywood may have been an upgrade, but frankly he hasn't lived up to his recruiting hype and isn't very good either. 

 I agree that Heywood hasn't lived up to the hype. But I still think they miss him due to the fact that his presence would (I assume) put Wilkins on the bench.

Posted

Even though the Badgers are terrible, I think Minnesota is going to have a real tough time coming to Madison and winning.  They have now lost 4 out of 5, and two of those games are blowout road losses to Purdue and Penn State. 

Posted
1 minute ago, JosephC said:

Even though the Badgers are terrible, I think Minnesota is going to have a real tough time coming to Madison and winning.  They have now lost 4 out of 5, and two of those games are blowout road losses to Purdue and Penn State. 

I don't know. PJ seems to have our number no matter what the circumstances.

Posted
2 hours ago, JosephC said:

Even though the Badgers are terrible, I think Minnesota is going to have a real tough time coming to Madison and winning.  They have now lost 4 out of 5, and two of those games are blowout road losses to Purdue and Penn State. 

Counterpoint: the Badgers are led by Luke Fickell and can (and will) lose to anyone. 

Posted
7 hours ago, yourout said:

I don't know. PJ seems to have our number no matter what the circumstances.

Lately, yeah. I think UW's only chance to win that one is if the defense comes out firing---they HAVE done that at times---and both holds down the Minny offense AND can turn them over a few times. I don't see this O-Line doing enough on its own to fuel enough offense in what should be, if nothing else, a very physical game. So get a couple gifts, some short fields, maybe win 17-13 or something like that.

That doesn't even speak to next weeks' game. It should be quite interesting to see how they come out for that one, between the ears & inside the ribcage. The 'Fire Fickell' hue & cry has been fueled by a lot of knee-jerk stuff early on in his tenure, both on-the-field stuff & off. Much of it was unrealistic due to the contractual obligations. It now has a real air of legitimacy to it. I can't wait to see how the players respond to that.

 

Posted

Fleck just fired the offensive coordinator.  Within Big 10 play, Minnesota has scored less points than Wisconsin in a equal number of games played.

In Big 10 games, Badgers are 3-0 at home and 1-3 on the road.  The Badgers showed yesterday that they can lose to ANY Big 10 team on the road.  Minnesota is only 1-3 on the road within the Big 10.  Purdue obliterated Minnesota in a game at Purdue this season (41-13).  I wouldn't be surprised if the road game at Purdue isn't more of a challenge than the Minnesota game.  But when you are talking about a bunch of mediocre to sub-par to bad teams playing one another, I guess anything can happen.

Posted
1 hour ago, Jim French Stepstool said:

Lately, yeah. I think UW's only chance to win that one is if the defense comes out firing---they HAVE done that at times---and both holds down the Minny offense AND can turn them over a few times. I don't see this O-Line doing enough on its own to fuel enough offense in what should be, if nothing else, a very physical game. So get a couple gifts, some short fields, maybe win 17-13 or something like that.

That doesn't even speak to next weeks' game. It should be quite interesting to see how they come out for that one, between the ears & inside the ribcage. The 'Fire Fickell' hue & cry has been fueled by a lot of knee-jerk stuff early on in his tenure, both on-the-field stuff & off. Much of it was unrealistic due to the contractual obligations. It now has a real air of legitimacy to it. I can't wait to see how the players respond to that.

 

I would hope losing to Purdue next week would make the ax game completely irrelevant relative to Fickell getting canned.

Posted
55 minutes ago, yourout said:

I would hope losing to Purdue next week would make the ax game completely irrelevant relative to Fickell getting canned.

I would think so. Like I said, my guess is that winning out would give him his only chance of sticking around.

Posted

Frustrating game, you're starting that QB because he can throw and then you don't let him throw downfield at all. Might as well have just done option read running with Joseph.  But the crux of the problems with the team is all OL. If they keep this staff that has to be the priority next year on where to spend money, along with keeping the D good. My hope is keeping Hopkins is a cheaper QB route than chasing in the portal for a C level guy like they've been doing the last few years, so it would free up OL money.  What's funny is they had to fire Chryst because of our outdated O, and now they realize why that was in place and have been trying to go back to it for the last two years but can't because they destroyed the OL system. 

My guess is if he wins both games they for sure keep him. 8-4 was probably the target before the year and they hit it. Frustrating to have the Iowa game be so bad, and to blow the game at MD that could've helped them look better, but goal still accomplished and obviously they are much better this year than the last two.  If they beat Pur and lose MN to finish 7-5 I think its a coinflip and can see it either way.  My guess would be they still keep him, as long as the MN loss isn't a bad blowout. And that it would purely be out of financial to save that 20 mil, one more year presumably drops it another 8ish mil. It is sound logically to spend the 20 mil on players rather than a buyout, unless you think you have the perfect hire (granted, they thought Fick was that hire so...)

Side note, the two big games on Saturday would essentially be meaningless in the new playoff system. A way to think of it that I forgot in that discussion the other day, if you continue to tell everyone that nothing matters but ringz/playoffs then people will eventually listen and stop caring until the playoffs. You're starting to see it already with empty stadiums for major programs.  In the past, you pushed and got people to care about the regional rivalries, conference, bowls, pride of beating your neighbor, general pageantry etc. Now we've told them none of that matters, just ringz and gambling.

  • Like 1
Posted
6 hours ago, tmwiese55 said:

 

My guess is if he wins both games they for sure keep him. 8-4 was probably the target before the year and they hit it.

To me it's really hard to believe that a Wisconsin football coach would be fired with an 8-4 regular season record unless there was some on-the-field incident that made the university look bad.  But I am in Dane County, and since the Iowa game the mood has been very down and the Maryland game has put it at rock bottom.  They are 6-4 right now and last year they were 3-7 after 10 games, but I can tell you that the mood locally isn't any better than it was last year.

It's so bad that I don't know if the record even matters anymore.

Posted
21 hours ago, tmwiese55 said:

  What's funny is they had to fire Chryst because of our outdated O, and now they realize why that was in place and have been trying to go back to it for the last two years but can't because they destroyed the OL system. 

 

Side note, the two big games on Saturday would essentially be meaningless in the new playoff system. A way to think of it that I forgot in that discussion the other day, if you continue to tell everyone that nothing matters but ringz/playoffs then people will eventually listen and stop caring until the playoffs. You're starting to see it already with empty stadiums for major programs.  In the past, you pushed and got people to care about the regional rivalries, conference, bowls, pride of beating your neighbor, etc. Now we've told them none of that matters, just ringz and gambling.

There was a lot of 'ear candy' about Longo & the new system right off the bat. I remember the very first game Fickell coached the team. We were getting little or no push from the O-line, and there were a lot of short passes to receivers & backs about 1 yard off the line of scrimmage with very little YAC yardage because there was no reason for the defense to be compacted between the tackles. I remember one or two series in thinking 'uh oh'.

Your last paragraph is absolute gold. It's just my personal opinion, but to me both college hoops & college FB have done things that make them more like the NBA & NFL, which is the definition of insanity because they're emulating a product that they were already much more entertaining than.

  • Like 1
Posted

Just saw our 2028 schedule, its about as brutal as the two years before this one.  Next year is joke level easy though, so I could see that supporting an argument to fire in order to allow the new guy a year to get ramped up and start with some positivity.  If you fire next year, then he's walking into a gauntlet and starting behind the 8 ball not unlike what Fickell faced with the schedules.   

OTOH, with that coming you could look at is well Fickell gets one more easy year next year to hopefully improve a level again like they did this year, then hopefully can be competitive in 28.    That's me trying to look at it objectively and broadly, as I've said on here before living in Madison and knowing people in the program it is a mess and they really should just fire and move on.  I'm sure the buyout is the only thing preventing that 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...