Okay, let me start by saying that I think Trevor Bauer is a first class jerk. Emotionally, I’m pleased that his punishment was severe. However, I’m also somewhat uncomfortable with this brand of justice when he’s been legally absolved. I do consider him a questionably ethical person, but should my opinion about an unproven accusation be a reason to cost someone their job.
A further complication comes when we consider the history of such accusations when it comes to celebrities. Many times celebrities are trapped by those looking to make a buck, and yet it’s just as true that often celebrities think they can take advantage of those who are attracted to them. Furthermore, and more than just a little obvious, is that none of us were there. None of us were privy to testimony and material evidence. This makes us less than qualified to pass judgement.
But most of all, we are naturally prone to draw conclusions on limited information. I’m as guilty as anyone of this, and so we (I) too often make judgement on people’s personalities and since Trevor Bauer lacks a compelling set of personality traits we (I) are prone to hate on him and wish him the worst. This natural propensity stands in direct opposition to the rule of law and so can be dangerous if we (I) get it wrong.