I was about to write that Votto has had success against Suppan (very small sample size - 4 for 7 with 1 HR and 4 RBI), so that might have come into play, but then I saw that Votto had been 2 for 2 against Shouse before the game. At any rate, I can see both arguments. I would've been cool with Suppan staying in, but I liked the move Yost made. For all we know, Suppan was getting a bit tired and Yost told him before the inning that he would yank him if a runner got on. Shouse almost always gets the lefty out, so you might as well go with the percentages. As strawboss said (which I had not thought about previously), if Dunn and Griffey come up in the 9th, Gagne is facing them, anyway.