This is exactly how it is theoretically setup in the NFL, yet nothing close to this happens. They use the term "indisputable video evidance" which should mean the ref should get 1 look for 10 seconds under the hood and if it isnt obvious move on. Instead what happens is automatic commercial break, Ref and production crew look at 10 different angles in super slow motion and they come back from the break showing the "best" view and the 2 analysts disagree with each on what should happen and the ref gets the call wrong anyways. This happens because the refs know these same shots will be all over sportscenter and the internet and the mindless drones of fans who love instant replay will obsess over the fraction of an inch the ref missed so he will take as long as he can to make the decision so he doesn't have this "wrong call" on his record. It is easy to sit around with all these good theoretical ideas about replay but WE HAVE PROOF that they will not get implemented the way we want. There WILL NEVER be an extra guy in the booth who just quickly reviews every play and in 10 seconds signals down to the ref to change it. A bad call = bad luck, its part of any sport or system as complicated as baseball. If you prefer something with no luck involved then watch track and field. We all know usually the best statistical team doesn't win the world series, so why is that ok (for some I'm sure it isnt)? If you love instant replay then why dont you support getting rid of the playoffs completely and just crowning the team with the best pythagorian winning %? Why is it ok to make the last out of the game on a stinging line drive with the winning run on base? That is terrible luck? If you love instant replay then why dont you support awarding guys first base if say an infielder catches a line drive off their bat in less than .8 seconds? Do you think that should be an out because "it is part of the game" or "thats the way its always been" What are you 150 years old, do you ride your horse to work still? Get with the times you old school fogey. The batter clearly won the matchup with the pitcher yet the pitchers gets rewarded based on luck.