For sures: Fielder, Utley, Wright, Dunn, Hart, Sheets, Smoltz I probably would: Halladay, Carmona, and Beltre The reasoning: I think that you have enough youth and pitching that Hughes isn't as important to you, and I wouldn't keep 5 pitchers. Pitching is also way easier to get in season. Posada is a good catcher, but he's coming off a career year and probably not worth a keeper unless you look around and 4 or 5 teams are keeping a catcher, then I would replace Belte with Posada. Everyone is upset with Beltre because of his huge drop off after his MVP type year, but he still put up solid numbers last year. I wouldn't keep Burnett because you already have Sheets and Halladay, you don't need 3 pitchers with that much injury risk.