Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

MNBrew

Verified Member
  • Posts

    3,111
  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Blogs

Events

Milwaukee Brewers News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Top Prospect Rankings

Milwaukee Brewers Videos

2022 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Milwaukee Brewers Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Milwaukee Brewers Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2024 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by MNBrew

  1. I think this is an interesting move -- I don't love it or hate it, though I can understand the arguments for both sides. It seems to me that this move serves some purpose(s) beyond itself. Opening roster spots? Salary space for one or more new acquisitions? Something else? Multiple moves/layers? Time will tell, and I'm curious, which surely also requires some patience.
  2. I think Santana returning would be a positive thing. Something close to last year's production (offense & defense) in a similar salary range as last year would seem like a solid & reasonable deal. Good veteran leadership on a team with a growing number of young position players also seems worthwhile. I like the Hoskins idea, too, but it seems like there would be more competition for him on the FA market.
  3. After last year, it'd be surprising if, barring injuries, Ashby fit anywhere other than Nashville to start the year. I love what he could be, but he hasn't shown he's back to that level yet.
  4. Yes, the Twins are interested in a lower 2024 payroll. But they were a playoff team with every intent of contending again, and as such are not just looking to sluff off their better players, meaning they like Polanco for the same reasons we do. That's why the names of Vazquez & Kepler are mentioned.
  5. He was optioned, so that's an option. Because he didn't stay down for 20 days, he doesn't lose any MLB service time between when he went down & came back up.
  6. I like Canha and would have loved to see him back. However, I agree with those who feel the $11.5M price tag was too steep. This move saves us the $2M buyout and gains the system an arm that's shown improvement. If a bigger move isn't out there, I'd love to see Santana return. Super solid D & fair bat w/ good power for a reasonable price should be > than the $11.5M for what would hopefully the best of Mark Canha. I'd love a Pete Alonso addition, too, but I'm not sure how likely that possibility now is. Black at 3B seems to hold some promise. Monasterio's nothing flashy, but he's serviceable and sure would've been a better bat in the lineup overall than Donaldson (Mr. GIDP) was. I love hot prospects like everyone else, but they take time to develop, even with hot MLB starts. I hope Wiemer, Turang, & Frelick are long-term, successful Brewers. But their initial bursts all were followed with them returning to earth. The promise is still there. The hope is that it'll still develop & become realized.
  7. Oh, I agree it's a fair price. I just like Strzelecki & didn't want to lose him. . . . Not arguing. Separate thoughts that can happily coexist.
  8. Peter Strzelecki . . . who I didn't want to lose.
  9. I'd think Blake Perkins has a better chance of being sent down than Toro or Miller. Perkins hasn't hit much of anything lately.
  10. My list is similar. My variations: I think Brosseau's got a better shot than Toro. Perkins has yet to see a regular season MLB active roster. I don't think his first time is Opening Day. Unless they move him or he's an absolute wreck in ST, I think Hiura is a near-lock for the Opening Day roster. I'm intrigued by Varland, but I don't think he has a snowball's chance of making the OD roster over Matt Bush. I also see both Miley & Houser on the OD roster, but they didn't sign Miley to a $5M contract to be a long man out of the BP. Houser's been inconsistent enough that I think he's in that role. .... Like someone else noted above, barring injuries, I wouldn't be surprised if an IF is moved before Opening Day, as well as one SP-type (Houser?).
  11. And with the Anderson signing, the Brewers have definitely exceeded critical mass in terms of quality IF depth. It seems pretty certain that going forward, there's not room on this roster for all of those folks. Soooo..... hmmm......
  12. Living in MN & watching plenty of Twins games, I can say this with reasonable confidence: Arraez is a batting champion and has been a strong hitter in the majors the whole time. He's no defensive nightmare and he can play a lot of positions. Regardless of what some of the defensive metrics say, his defense isn't bad. He's easily the most valuable asset in the proposed trade and not someone the Twins "just won't have room for." To try to reduce him to being worth very replaceable, pedestrian "power but not much else" sell-low Brewers hitters is a gross underestimation of Arraez's game and worth. I'd love to have Arraez on the Brewers. He's 25 years old and a .314 career hitter (.374 OBP, .784 OPS -- good for a non-power hitter) who doesn't walk a lot but strikes out even less -- a 4.4 bWAR player last year & 10.4 for his 4-year career. The Twins pretty clearly don't want to move him. The rumblings around the winter meetings were a one-time report that the Twins might be open to moving him if it might help them obtain really good pitching. What's been perpetuated since then were repetitions of that one report, not additional/ongoing reports.
  13. That's essentially what the rest of my post was saying. Barring a lot of injuries, I'd rather they be pitching in AAA unless they prove pretty clearly that they're worthy of an MLB roster spot (starting with the "cup of coffee" variety, just to be clear).
  14. I haven't paid enough attention to the details about any of them, but I'd include Janson Junk, Bryse Wilson, & Tyson Miller as additional SP depth beyond Miley. Miley may well be the only one who bumps several people down the list, whereas Junk/Wilson/Miller and whomever else probably all slot into the AAA rotation as MLB safety-net guys. I agree that hanging onto most of that depth is both needed and also the best move as opposed to sending some of that depth off in a trade right now (assuming such a trade isn't of the can't-refuse/blow-us-away variety).
  15. I haven't paid enough attention to the details about any of them, but I'd include Janson Junk, Bryse Wilson, & Tyson Miller as additional SP depth beyond Miley. Miley may well be the only one who bumps several people down the list, whereas Junk/Wilson/Miller and whomever else probably all slot into the AAA rotation as MLB safety-net guys. I agree that hanging onto most of that depth is both needed and also the best move as opposed to sending some of that depth off in a trade right now (assuming such a trade isn't of the can't-refuse/blow-us-away variety).
  16. The guys the Brewers sign each year for Nashville generally all evoke a similar reaction. That's why they're mainly signed to AAA contracts. As Stearns said a few times over the years, they have to field a full team in Nashville, too -- and the AAA roster's never made up entirely of prospects.
  17. Seems like he just made it up. That a guy like this has **this** big of a scoop yet no one else anywhere -- not one of the big-time national guys (Rosenthal, Morosi, etc.) -- has mentioned it suggests it's likely a bunch of hot air.
  18. I looked at his page as well as the replies to his post. Seems like a classic haughty talk radio bluster type of guy. Most of the 90+ responses to this particular tweet were calling him out or calling him names. His follower count means little in terms of actual credibility. Maybe he's onto something, but I highly doubt it. If he's actually right, kudos to him.
  19. A Urias extension could be a smart move looking back 5 years from now. Or it could look really stupid. I want to see more from him before talking about an extension.
  20. Trevor Bauer the pitcher could be a really intriguing addition, whether in MIL or elsewhere. Clearly it's not that simple due to choices he made.
  21. I like Escobar -- his track record, his versatility, his veteran presence -- but I'd be a little concerned about decline. Power's still solid, but his BA has trended downward, ditto his OBP (2 of the last 3 years under .300), & his K's are way up the last 4 (full) years It could be a move that would pan out & fit our needs quite well. Or it could become McCutchen 2.0. Meanwhile, I'm intrigued by the potential of Hiura, Toro, & Turang, plus what we know Brosseau brings. If Escobar becomes a Brewer, I'd hate to see so many of those guys get squeezed. On the other hand, if Escobar becomes a Brewer without the Crew giving up any of those four players, then that's a real plus in terms of depth.
  22. I like Escobar -- his track record, his versatility, his veteran presence -- but I'd be a little concerned about decline. Power's still solid, but his BA has trended downward, ditto his OBP (2 of the last 3 years under .300), & his K's are way up the last 4 (full) years It could be a move that would pan out & fit our needs quite well. Or it could become McCutchen 2.0. Meanwhile, I'm intrigued by the potential of Hiura, Toro, & Turang, plus what we know Brosseau brings. If Escobar becomes a Brewer, I'd hate to see so many of those guys get squeezed. On the other hand, if Escobar becomes a Brewer without the Crew giving up any of those four players, then that's a real plus in terms of depth.
  23. I've liked Escobar since he first started producing well for the Twins. I was glad when they picked him up at the '21 deadline. I like the idea of him as a Brewer again. All that said, I'm not sure where or how well he fits given the other pieces already on the roster (Urias, Turang if he makes the OD roster, Brosseau, Miller, & Hiura). If Matt Arnold thinks he's an upgrade, I'm fine with it. Good IF depth is a nice thing to have, though I'd think there's no way ALL those guys are on the OD roster (obviously Turang & Miller have options).
  24. It's a well-written, well-researched item in that article, but it's pretty clear Rosenthal is just speculating. Unless there's a deal that's to good not to make, I don't think there's any way the Brewers are in a hurry to trade another of their top OF prospects. If their cadre of OF prospects is that strong, I think they need to make any move with an eye to the long view, not the short one. I love trades as much as the next guy, but this is one situation where I'm not eager to see a 2nd OF prospect moved this winter. There's also plenty of time left in this offseason. No need to rush into anything.
×
×
  • Create New...