Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
  • Brewers News & Analysis

    Willy Adames Has a Broken Swing, and Worse, He Knows It


    Matthew Trueblood

    In his walk year, the Brewers' star shortstop and clubhouse linchpin has struggled through as tough a grind as he's had in a long time. His power has dried up, and with it, his confidence. How can he turn it around?

    Image courtesy of © Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

    Brewers Video

    In an ugly loss Tuesday night, the silver lining was a 1-for-3 night from Willy Adames, including a double and a walk. It was a sign of life, amid what has been a desert of production for the slugger. He's lived a tale of two seasons this year. Through May 31, he was hitting .256/.335/.453, with solid strikeout and walk rates and a hard-hit rate over 40%. Since then, he's cratered. In 35 games since Jun. 1, Adames is at .198/.304/.317, striking out close to 24% of the time and with his hard-hit rate down to 35.5%. Nothing's working.

    As much as he tries to be a well-rounded hitter, when Adames is at his best, he's a home run guy. He lifts the ball, and puts it close to the fences, if not over them. Early this year, when he was going well, he not only hit for actual power, but was robbed of would-be extra-base hits at the wall multiple times. Since Jun. 23, though, Adames hasn't hit the ball even 330 feet in the air.

    Screenshot 2024-07-10 093928.png

    Not hitting home runs is one thing. Not hitting even warning-track fly balls is another. Adames is not right at all, and as he's become more aware of the issue, the problem is only getting worse. He had a hard-hit rate of nearly 49% and an OPS of .826 on pitches in the lower third of the zone through June 23. Since then, the hard-hit rate is under 31%, the OPS is .367, and worst of all, he's virtually given up on that part of the zone.

    Screenshot 2024-07-10 094412.png

    Focusing on the upper half of the zone has been Adames's way of compensating for a swing he knows is out of whack. Unfortunately, it's made more of his hard-hit balls come off the bat at a lower trajectory, eating into his power.

    You can see the problem in the way he swings at low pitches, when he does so. Early in the season, when he was doing damage on those offerings, it was by driving cleanly through the ball. He was looking for the ball down in the zone, and when he got it, he was able to put his 'A' swing on it, attacking center and right-center field.

    When he's right--when he's covering the whole zone, with an adaptable but quick swing--Adames can turn on and pull that ball on the upper or inner half, but strides right through the ball and stays closed on those pitches down. Recently, though, he's pulling off those balls, leading to weak contact on the ground to the left side.

    The margins that separate success and failure in baseball are shockingly small--sometimes cruelly so. Adames isn't a totally different hitter, but he's a far, far less effective one right now. He's a little bit off, and the efforts he's made to counteract his struggles have, instead, only magnified them.

    With more called strikes because of his diminished aggressiveness, more whiffs because he's unable to cover the whole of the zone, and less production because the long fly ball is missing from his game, Adames continues to scuffle. Hopefully, Tuesday night was the beginning of a turn in the right direction, but it's been a brutal six weeks for the Crew's beloved leader and frequent cleanup man.

    Follow Brewer Fanatic For Milwaukee Brewers News & Analysis

    • Like 1

    Recent Brewers Articles

    Recent Brewers Videos

    Brewers Top Prospects

    Brandon Sproat

    Milwaukee Brewers - MLB, RHP
    Sproat had a rough first appearance in a Brewers uniform (3 IP, 7 ER, 3 HR). On Thursday, he gave up one run on 4 hits and a walk over 6 2/3 innings. He struck out six Blue Jays batters.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments

    Yes, but let's still sign him to a well over nine-figure contract extension because that's the going rate for good defensive shortstops who occasionally get hot at the plate

    I don't hate Adames as a player, but I'm going to be glad moving on from him as a Brewer next offseason because he's maddeningly inconsistent offensively and approaching the age where his steady defensive value at SS will tank.

    • Like 3

    He tries to hit for for power all the time but you won't have any batting average success at all with that approach.  Pitchers will just pitch him low and outside and he either can't or won't won't adjust for that.  He just needs to try hit a line drive the way high average hitters do every day of the week and forget blasting it over the fence every at bat unless its middle middle. 

    • Like 2
    14 minutes ago, Brian said:

    He tries to hit for for power all the time but you won't have any batting average success at all with that approach.  Pitchers will just pitch him low and outside and he either can't or won't won't adjust for that.  He just needs to try hit a line drive the way high average hitters do every day of the week and forget blasting it over the fence every at bat unless its middle middle. 

    Also, Murphy could help him out by getting him out of the #4 cleanup spot and moving him in the order.

    Either up or down it doesn't matter to me, just get him out of the #4 power spot. 

    3 hours ago, Brian said:

    He tries to hit for for power all the time but you won't have any batting average success at all with that approach.  Pitchers will just pitch him low and outside and he either can't or won't won't adjust for that.  He just needs to try hit a line drive the way high average hitters do every day of the week and forget blasting it over the fence every at bat unless its middle middle. 

    He needs to get solid contact.  The difference between Adames and Contreras is Contreras is content hitting from left-center to right-center.  Adames has great hitting games when he comes to the plate with that approach.  See ball, hit ball can't be his approach.  He needs to have a plan.

    Now, he may have a plan.  If he does, it isn't a good one or it isn't working.  His hips and hands are out of sync for sure.

    • Like 1

    I think Willy is always going to run hot-cold, and the cold stretches are always going to last longer than we think they should. He struck out twice last night, and his double was to the pull side. That in itself doesn't give me a lot of hope that he's coming out of it because his turnarounds usually seem to come when he starts driving the ball to the right side (I think he did that a little in LA). 

    He'll come out of it at some point. Then you just hope the good stretch lasts as long as possible.

    I think the key to moving him down in the order rests with breaking up the Turang-Contreras-Yelich trio at the top. I'd prefer (when he returns) Ortiz 2nd w/Contreras 4th. Chourio is doing much better in recent weeks hitting in the bottom third; IMO leave him there at this stage of his career. What I THINK will happen is Adames will stay in the cleanup spot & they'll ride it out. On one of the top half-dozen or so lineups in MLB he'd hit around 7th & be just fine there.

    • Like 2


    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...