You also need take home runs, triples, a portion of the doubles and pop ups out of the equation. All of the sudden, it isn't such a good idea. I see what you are saying. Those are neutral in terms of benefit. So 24.8% K rate 16 doubles(12), triples(1) & HR(3) / 193 plate apperances = 8.2% Remainder is 67% he does something else. Now you have to deduct the negatives of all outs that are made in the air. That will really reduce the benefit. The only positive out is a hard hit ground ball. With one out I can see it once in a while. With no one out I don't think it is a very good idea.