I'm pretty down on Melvin myself. When Dean Taylor was hired, he said "The big club will not win in 2 or 3 years. The entire organization is in a shambles, and needs to be rebuilt from the bottom up" (or words to that effect). Many of us were ecstatic. Finally we had a guy that was willing to tell it like it was, and take the proper steps to fix it. Of course, when the big team wasn't winning within a couple of years, Taylor was shown the door. But in that short time, our farm system had gone from being one of the worst in all of baseball, to being pretty darn good. Melvin inherited a pretty decent farm, with what appeared to be a plan for success already in place, yet here we are 8 years later and we're still scrambling for starting pitching. I realize that every pick doesn't work out, and that pitchers are probably the biggest "crap shoot" of all; but we seem to be struggling with this big, gaping hole throughout the system, and have been for a number of years now. The small/mid market thing means we absolutely have to develop our own players, with the occasional trade such as Sabathia, or big-ticket free agent signing to make a push when the opportunity presents itself. Over-paying for aging free agents is never going to be a good plan. I'm okay with Wolf thus far, but others have been disastrous. Suppan, Davis, Riske, Gagne, Hawkins, Hoffman to a degree, etc, etc, etc, on and on and on. Now we've drafted a lot of pitching, which is needed, but will we now experience a drought in home-grown position players? How many times will this pendulum swing back and forth before we achieve some kind of balance? I'm not looking to debate Taylor vs Melvin as GM, but if my memory is right Taylor did do an excellent job with the farm. Of course, my senility has been acting up lately, so maybe I'm remembering it all wrong. If I am, I'm sure I'll be corrected (and gladly).