I think the 2010 team had a ton more depth/talent than what this version of the Packers has.
Starks came on late to give them enough running the ball with a prime Rodgers still having Nelson, Jennings, Jones, and Driver to throw to. The Oline missed Tausch, but still had Sitton, Wells, Clifton, Bulaga, Lang, and Colledge as a primary backup. Raji/Cullen Jenkins, Prime Clay with Hawk and Bishop in the middle, and a secondary with Tramon, Woodson, Collins, Bigby, and Sam Shields was dynamic.
I'll give you Finley getting knocked out as comparable to Kraft - but would that team have gone all the way if Nelson missed the 1st half the year while Jennings missed most of meat of the season (similar to Watson/Reed), Sitton and Wells going down while Clifton or Bulaga fought knee issues late in the year, Raji and Clay blowing out knees in late November/early December? No chance.