I do agree that the nature of baseball makes it difficult to determine exactly what sorts of calls should be subject to review and that there likely needs to be some limit put on how many reviews that can be made (potentially reviewing every safe/out call, for example, would be nuts), but to be against replay because of tradition or the desire to maintain the "human element" of the game is just absurd.
I feel bad watching Chris Davis (a DH) try to pitch the 17th for the O's against the Red Sox. He has a 3-run lead and it feels like it's an auto-loss. EDIT: And he strikes out Adrian Gonzalez the forces a DP. EDIT 2: Thanks, MLB Network for not going split screen with the Brewers like you said you would.
It was TOTALLY a make-up call. And people can criticize RR all they want for not getting tossed, but it sure looked like he accused the ump of a make-up call, as well. RR was pretty damn mad - he just didn't go so crazy to get himself tossed.
By the way, is it just me, or does it seem like the Giants play every game at home? No matter what day it is, if I see a Giants highlight on TV or catch a few minutes of a game live, it's always in SF.