No. I'll elaborate briefly. Without even looking at the numbers, at no point in his career have I ever thought, "Holy cow, this guy is amazing. This guy is truly an elite player of his generation." I know that's really simplistic and not giving him enough credit for his accomplishments, but he just doesn't pass the eyeball test to me. He's been a really good player and I like him, but I think he's a notch below elite. Same goes for Johnny Damon.