Of course, Black is not on this list, but I’m still not convinced that he is likely to be a positive contributor.
I realize that my opinion is based on an eye test drawn from a relatively small sample of PA’s. But, my impression is that a disproportionate portion of his successful AB’s have come in the lopsided wins against lower tier pitchers, or pitchers who are having bad games who are being hit by everyone. He looked completely overmatched with defensive swings last night.
its a vicious circle, and maybe he needs more ABs to show he’s more than a replacement level player. Even against a RHP I’d rather see those ABs going to Vaughn.