If you want to go down this path I could use something similar to highlight my questions about the Brewers offense.
For one thing, I don’t think this season has been that much of a roller coaster so far. It’s nothing compared to the Cubs or the Braves (which has been more of a steep climb followed by a steep descent).
The Brewers had a good first week followed by a bad streak that brought them back to .500. Since then it’s been a mostly uphill climb without the dramatic winning streaks from the second half of last year.
But I think the way you divided up the games presents a misleading picture of what the Brewers offense was like in that middle block of 38 games. I’d have to spend some time getting the precise numbers, but that block seems to include the two 13 run games against at the end of April and the high scoring games in early June against the Giants, Rockies and A’s. Those games whitewash the whole month of May in which the Brewers offense was middle of the pack (something like 4.3 RPG)
The next two groups covering 29 games show the Brewers scoring around 4.5 RPG.
If we just looked at the games from May 1 on, there would be about 10 weeks of the Brewers averaging about 4.5 RPG with one block of exceptionally high scoring games in the middle.
These are all facts that we can each interpret how we want for purposes of evaluating the Brewers offense and what we can expect from it going forward. I think we would all agree that the games in Colorado and Vegas are aberrations and are not very relevant for projecting future performance, especially because the Brewers won’t be visiting either place again.
My conclusion from this is, at least for now, the Brewers offense is more of a middle of the pack 4.5 RPG offense than an elite 5 RPG offense. But that run prevention has been undeniably elite and that’s why the Brewers have been winning at the rate they have been.