At least one team in the HCS Championship Game should automatically be given to an ACC team. I think the ACC is a weak conference. At least weaker than the Big East and even the Big 10 lately. First, there's travel costs; it's one thing to fly 20 people around carrying basketball uniforms and shoes, flying 100 people with football equipment (plus a band and band equipment) is a lot greater cost. It's not just revenue, it's revenue minus costs. Right, but they make due with one game because of tv revenue and ticket sales along with other sponsorships. They'll be more games to add more revenue to help offset any costs. The non-D-1 schools do it, but they also aren't spending $1.5M on football scholarships (plus $2M on coaches salaries). Most football programs are in the red already; that's why teams love to play UW in non-conference games The non-D1 schools also don't have anywhere close to the amount of fans D1 schools do. They also don't make the same off of merchandise sales. D1 schools have a lot more sources of income than non D1 schools. Also, teams in the red can still schedule those games to make money. Nothing will change with that. And if they happen to make the tournament, I'm sure they'll come out ahead. So think about that - if Wisconsin was one of the teams in the tournament, would you have gone to the Rose Bowl or would you have waited to see if they beat TCU and made it to the 2nd round or championship game? That is a good point. But I think the lost ticket sales from students and alum will at least partially be made up by locals buying more tickets. I think a lot of the people who go to the basketball tournament games are locals and people would be more willing to go to a tournament game than a bowl game. Beside, if you look at some of the non-marquee bowl games, those stadiums are embarrassingly empty too. It's not like all the bowl games draw 90,000 fans. The Beef O Brady bowl drew 20,000 fans. The Humanitarian Bowl 25,000 and the New Orleans Bowl a shade under 30,000. That's not good for college football (even Big East football average 40,000 fans). if a star player gets hurt (like Brian Butch did), or if you have one bad officiating call in an early round game (like the Big East tournament this year) the best team may not even make it to the championship game. The thing is, how do you determine who the "best team" is every year? How can you convince TCU fans that Oregon and Auburn were both better than them, especially after TCU beat Wisconsin? My ideal tournament would include 16 teams and 4 rounds, but I'd be ok with a 12 team tournament with the top four seeds getting a bye.