Might be a bit late for the Brewers to lock up Turang. That said, now would be the time to do it. Like Hoerner, Turang is in his Year 1 of 4 arbitration seasons. Hoerner made $2.525 million in 2023. Turang is making $4.15 million in 2026.
Hoerner's previous extension was three years and $35 million and covered those final three years of arbitration. ($11.5M, $11.5M, $12M). Brewers could/should offer him three years and $41 million ($12M, $14M, $15M).
Hoerner's six-year extension is worth $141 million. ($23M, $23M, $22.5M, $22.5M, $22.5M, $22.5M)
I think Turang is a little better (IMO) than Hoerner, so he should get a little bit more. So as not to overthink, I'll say six years and $150 million for those six free agent seasons. ($26M, $26M, $25M, $25M, $24M, $24M)*
*If you believe that Turang is worth more than Hoerner by more than that $9M difference over six years. You could add another $4-10 million in a signing bonus. But I think that could also be limited somewhat by trying to get Turang to take a bit of a discount to stay in Milwaukee.
I'm sure the Brewers would be happy to sign him to a three year, $41 million to cover his arbitration years. Turang would probably be good with that as well since he'd still be a free agent at age 29.
Would the Brewers and/or Turang be willing to put the two deals together into one nine-year deal? Combined, it'd be nine years and $191 million. That's just over $20 million annually. I can't imagine the Brewers locking him up through age 35.