That's what makes this an inexact science, along with the player-non player question. For me:
Players only: Yount, Molitor, Braun, Yelich. Two of those guys were exclusive to Milwaukee & a third almost exclusive & will probably finish up here. that's a factor with me.
Everyone: Uecker, Yount, Molitor, Selig. Bud could've said 'screw it' & given up in the 5 years prior to the team arriving, and with the uphill struggle I don't think anyone would've blamed him. Braun/Molitor would be a good thumb wrestle for the 4th spot.
A 'Milwaukee baseball, players only' list would be a great debate to find a fourth: Aaron, Spahn, Yount &.............?