Replacement level is still 2 wins below average. I figured he would be close to replacement level. Close is a subjective term but the average MLB SS hit .262/.316/.378/.695. Betancourt .268/.271/.381/.652. I guess .381 is above .378 so sure his SLG is technically above average. Of course we wouldn't have gone any further with a replacement level SS. I didn't want a replacement level SS, I wanted an average one. To be honest, he hit even worse than I expected. Or 1B.Even Money said Gamel was okay at 1B this year. I'm pretty sure from the start you claimed he would be below replacement,(I'll have to dig back and look for specific quotes when I have the time, I'm fairly certain they exist). Fact is, he wasn't below replacement. Add to that that there were no "average" SS available in the past offseason, and I guess it just illustrates why some of us got so fed up with the over the top negativity...where many were stating that replacement level would be an improvement...it wouldn't have been. And 0 legitimate alternatives were ever discussed apart from the mythical "average SS", whoever that might be. This next year, there are a few better FA options at SS. I hope the Brewers make every effort to pursue those options.