The reason it's not valid to ask "what would you have done this offseason?" or "who would you have signed?" is that Melvin didn't just arrive on the scene this past offseason. He's been with the team since 2002, and all of the moves he has made along the way are exponential and have led the franchise to be in the exact state it was during the offseason. Just because there were not a lot of free agent options this year doesn't mean nothing could have been done differently. If Melvin had acquired any decent young pitching at all during the past handful of years, instead of spending all of his resources getting "major league ready talent" like Mench, Estrada, Graffanino, Vargas, Suppan, Gomez, etc, this team would probably be in a lot better shape. There's an unlimited amount of possibilities for how this team could be better now, but you have to go all the way back to when he took the reigns -- and it's obviously not practical to try and state what moves could have been made since each move since the beginning has had a lasting effect on the moves that can be made after. Also, we will never know what moves were available to him. Unless you believe there was no possible way Melvin could have obtained more good young pitching at any point during his 8-year tenure, the argument just doesn't really hold water.