I'll keep pimping win shares for these sorts of arguments. I've sorted them by fielding, and you can see Lee is tops in the NL, but there are three ahead of him by quite a bit in the AL including Oooooooo this year. And, you can easily conclude that Prince's bat makes up for the minor delta in fielding between him and Lee. Lee has had some incredible plays against us at first and his height really does seem to help him a lot, but he is very agile for a guy his size. It's hard not to wish we had him when you see that stuff. Objectively, however, he does not stack up.