Well, he might not tell the whole story, but I'm not sure if he flat out lies... He could say that he's not motivated to move Turnbow, and then trade him somewhere two days later. That isn't a lie, it's just a way of saying that he basically found an offer that included a return that met his expectations. As far as trading Carlos goes, he said about the same thing, but things changed as time went on and the odds kept getting better. Really, the same went with Overbay... He wasn't motivated, and all the sudden he was. This time, he said it was an internet rumor: "Melvin and assistant GM Gord Ash did chat with Phillies officials, including GM Pat Gillick, but Melvin dismissed talk of the deal as "an Internet rumor." Melvin asked the Phillies if they had interest in Jenkins and/or Mench, and "Pat Gillick says no," Melvin said. " I see that as a pretty direct statement. And while he might bend the truth and not tell the entire story, that just seems like a flat out denial. I can't think of a time when Melvin was that direct and have it turn around 180 degrees. Of course, maybe I'm just missing a few memories here and there.