Not necessarily, the market was different back then, proven MLB players carried much more weight, though we may have had to give up another prospect of significance, but it wouldn't have had to be Fielder. As far as Marcum vs Bush goes... it's not hindsight, Marcum threw slightly harder with better control... I view them as similar pitchers at the time, I would have taken the player with less MLB experience but slightly more upside. What's 2 MPH on the fastball worth? Probably not much in the grand scheme of things, I called Marcum a B prospect out of convenience to make my point, he was probably more like a C? type player. The point I was trying to illustrate was that Melvin seemed to be more interested in building depth acquiring multiple low ceiling players that were MLB ready and had MLB experience © than he was in acquiring impact talent. I'm not talking about trading for Peavy, Sabathia, Lee, Halladay, or any other proven MLB front line ace, they are simply too costly to pay and too costly to acquire. Many young pitchers have been moved in the last 5 years in deals that worked out very well, not necessarily in sexy type moves that garnered headlines. We've been in need of front line pitching depth since I found Brewerfan.net in 2003, we've never really had it, and the organization hasn't made any moves to acquire it. The only reason we have some top of the rotation depth approaching MLB now is the draft/signing process which is great, but won't start reaping benefits till next season at the earliest. That's quite the gap in the system... We went from Sheets in 2001 to Yo in 2007... who's going to be the next pitcher of significance to debut? Can we realistically only debut a single top of the rotation starter in 6 years and hope to remain competitive playoff wise? My answer to the question over the winter was "no" and I remain convinced that to win a WS we need very solid 1,2, 3 punch for the playoffs. Good pitching is greater than good hitting. We can get to the playoffs with an average staff if the offense is good enough, but we aren't winning anything until our pitching once again surpasses our hitting.