1. My main point is that JJ Hardy is not enough for Boston to part with Buchholz. We already have a major league talent evaluator saying as much in an article in the Boston Globe on Sunday. 2. Ellsbury's value is pretty low right now. I believe Ellsbury for Hardy to be a much more equitable trade. 3. Ellsbury would likely receive a "bump" from moving from the AL East to the NL Central. I believe he would be a 40 steal .350 OBP lead-off hitter for the Brewers. His lack of slugging is mostly immaterial as a lead-off hitter. This would allow the Brewers to save money by letting Cameron leave, as well as move Weeks down in the order (#2 hitter) to collect more RBIs. 4. It would create a hole for Boston in CF. But at this point, they have had Ellsbury batting as low as 8th - so I don't think Boston views it as nearly a big of a hole as a shortstop. Besides, Boston can always sign Cameron. 5. As an additional bonus, if Milwaukee loved Tony Gwynn - they will really love a lead-off hitter who can actually hit! Also, he can replace JJ Hardy as the team heartthrob.