Carmona for Parra?

[Hate those Rodents]

Looks like the Indians have sent Carmona down to rookie ball to try and help him. Many advocate Parra being sent down to try and help him as well. Not sure either player is at the "need a change of scenery" yet, but I just thought the idea might be interesting. Is it a fair trade/gamble for both teams?

[trwi7]

In his last 181.1 innings, Carmona has walked 111 and struck out 94. To be fair, he does get a lot of ground ball outs, but I don't see how that's a good deal for the Brewers at all.

[twobrewers]

I had given some thought to Carmona lately as well - then I looked at his numbers.

He was awesome for one season. The rest of his career - he has been horrible.

I'd rather live with Parra's mediocrity.