Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted

I have always understood the appeal of restricting "political" discussion on the site, and I have always objected to it, because it doesn't make any damn sense.

Trading for a player whose greatest notoriety over the past two years has been his political expression is an act with political content.  Limiting discussion of that player to "just baseball" is also an act with political content.  Does anyone really think the Walker discussion in the forum is somehow neutral?  It's not.  It's just censored.

We're allowed to talk about matters of stadium construction and sales taxes.  That stuff is literally, obviously political.  But apparently we aren't allowed to talk about whether LGBTQ+ fans feel welcome at our ballpark.  That's not political to me and a lot of other people.  That's personal.  That's my daughter.  That's some of my best friends.  But, you know, reasonable people can disagree.  Most people think my daughter is a full-scale human being, but some people think she deserves to burn forever in a lake of fire, so -- difference of opinion, what are you gonna do?  Reasonable disagreement.

I respect Brock's candor in saying shutting down discussion of this topic is to make the mods' lives easier.  On one hand, I sympathize.  I'm not a mod.  I don't like when my job gets hard.  I get it.  On the other hand, it's a discussion forum that exists in the world.  When you shut down discussion of a real world topic for the sake of ease and convenience, you take a position on the topic.  You say that whichever viewpoint prevails in silence gets to keep prevailing.  You need to own that choice.

BTW, the banner ad at the bottom of my screen as I'm typing these word says "Israel under attack!"  So I guess outright political provocation is fine on the site as long as you can pay for the privilege.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I appreciate the message, and I agree with you more than you realize. If this world wasn't such a colossal ******** about all things all the time, I'd probably have a different stance on this matter. But the world is what it is, and that's a steaming pile of ****ery run by tech oligarchs whose life mission it is to make us angry about literally everything, literally all the time.

There have been times in the past when we lift the veil because "enough is enough". But in the day-to-day of the world, we can't do that about literally everything that happens everywhere. And yeah, it's censorship. That's not necessarily a bad thing; we all deploy censorship in our personal lives. We've taken the stance that, barring specific incidents that fundamentally challenge who we are as a nation or even world, we keep politics off the site (our front-page writers are given more leeway to voice their thoughts).

There are literally 1,000 places to discuss every aspect of this situation. Most of them are steaming piles of ******* overrun by bad actors and bots. We try to be different, even if it's just in small ways every once in awhile.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Take a look at Brewerfan Political Scene. The whole place is people insulting each other. This forum has lasted a LONG time in large part because of moderation to avoid politics. If one wants Brewerfan to be every other place on the internet and allow it all, you'll get just that, just as you'll get more trolls, more low-quality posts and members coming and going. Brewerfan is very unique in that many of us are older and many of us have been posting for a decade+.

>There have been times in the past when we lift the veil because "enough is enough"

How have those times been received, though? For every Schwartz there's an equal and opposite Schwartz. Like the Roe v. Wade banner which was put up when the site first turned over certainly was considered by some to be one of those times, but others not so much (that was as neutral as I could get it).

I've been an active poster on this site for 20 years and if we allowed politics I'd leave. This is the only friendly place on the internet I know of, but I know just what would happen if we started allowing it.

 

Posted
19 minutes ago, GAME05 said:

Take a look at Brewerfan Political Scene. The whole place is people insulting each other. This forum has lasted a LONG time in large part because of moderation to avoid politics. If one wants Brewerfan to be every other place on the internet and allow it all, you'll get just that, just as you'll get more trolls, more low-quality posts and members coming and going. Brewerfan is very unique in that many of us are older and many of us have been posting for a decade+.

I'd like to elaborate on this a bit. I run a lot of communities, and I try to take the best from all of them. Some communities are more neutral; others are more leftist. Others are more lax in moderation, while some are stricter.

I personally enjoy the left-leaning communities more than the neutral communities; they tend to be funnier, but also gentler. But any community that is wholly one way or the other got there through ugly means; posters fighting until one side "won" and drove off the other side. We're not robots; if the reins are loosened, that doesn't contain itself to a single thread or topic. It spreads, as people align themselves with people they agree with and become combative with those they don't. Ultimately, there's only one end to it: a weaker, more insular community with fewer members in it.

I've seen decades-long grudges between posters. I've seen so many cheapshots against other posters based on something that happened 15 years ago. And what I've quietly discovered over the years is all the people I DON'T know because they were driven off years ago, and I either never knew them or forgot about them.

And on top of all of this, it puts an enormous strain on moderator crews. Many leave because they just get sick and tired of the babysitting. It's not what they signed up to do when they became a moderator on a baseball website. In the end, nothing good comes from opening the floodgates, while a hell of a lot of bad is basically assured.

 

Posted

I appreciate the discussion, and I greatly respect where you're coming from.  Brock, you've clearly given this a lot of thought, and you have a lot more experience with online communities than I do.  I also take your point about "censor," which I meant more descriptively than pejoratively.

I still don't buy the underlying logic, as familiar as it is (and certainly not unique to this site).  Like Bob Dylan sang, we live in a political world.  You don't find politics or avoid it; politics finds you.  When the Brewers trade for a guy, and he's coming out of a whole very public discourse about the effects of his actions on the LGBTQ+ community, barring discussion of that subject relative to him says, in effect, that he wasn't wrong; he said what he said, now let's just talk about baseball.  I don't mean to be harsh, and I certainly don't mean to ascribe Walker's beliefs to anyone here.  But, with the utmost respect, I think the consequence of letting the Brewers skate when they consciously decide to take on the baggage that travels with the player is that the baggage flies free.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...