gregmag
Verified Member-
Posts
2,217 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
gregmag last won the day on November 9
gregmag had the most liked content!
Recent Profile Visitors
The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.
gregmag's Achievements
-
I appreciate the discussion, and I greatly respect where you're coming from. Brock, you've clearly given this a lot of thought, and you have a lot more experience with online communities than I do. I also take your point about "censor," which I meant more descriptively than pejoratively. I still don't buy the underlying logic, as familiar as it is (and certainly not unique to this site). Like Bob Dylan sang, we live in a political world. You don't find politics or avoid it; politics finds you. When the Brewers trade for a guy, and he's coming out of a whole very public discourse about the effects of his actions on the LGBTQ+ community, barring discussion of that subject relative to him says, in effect, that he wasn't wrong; he said what he said, now let's just talk about baseball. I don't mean to be harsh, and I certainly don't mean to ascribe Walker's beliefs to anyone here. But, with the utmost respect, I think the consequence of letting the Brewers skate when they consciously decide to take on the baggage that travels with the player is that the baggage flies free.
-
Totally understandable that May's getting 3/52.5. I mean, he's bad, but at least he's injury prone. Absolute stink bomb of a trade. There is no theory under which May was useful to the Brewers. Any warm body could have pitched his bad innings badly. Getting Romero was sneaky brilliant, but Romero alone was worth Ragsdale at most. I can't believe an organization as smart as the Brewers made the trade to satisfy public pressure to "go for it," because that would be cowardly and idiotic -- but if that was their motive, they should hang May's stats on a prominent wall to deter them any time they're tempted to make another stupid deadline trade, which is to say just about any deadline trade. I hope May does fine I guess, but I'm very glad to be rid of him.
-
I have always understood the appeal of restricting "political" discussion on the site, and I have always objected to it, because it doesn't make any damn sense. Trading for a player whose greatest notoriety over the past two years has been his political expression is an act with political content. Limiting discussion of that player to "just baseball" is also an act with political content. Does anyone really think the Walker discussion in the forum is somehow neutral? It's not. It's just censored. We're allowed to talk about matters of stadium construction and sales taxes. That stuff is literally, obviously political. But apparently we aren't allowed to talk about whether LGBTQ+ fans feel welcome at our ballpark. That's not political to me and a lot of other people. That's personal. That's my daughter. That's some of my best friends. But, you know, reasonable people can disagree. Most people think my daughter is a full-scale human being, but some people think she deserves to burn forever in a lake of fire, so -- difference of opinion, what are you gonna do? Reasonable disagreement. I respect Brock's candor in saying shutting down discussion of this topic is to make the mods' lives easier. On one hand, I sympathize. I'm not a mod. I don't like when my job gets hard. I get it. On the other hand, it's a discussion forum that exists in the world. When you shut down discussion of a real world topic for the sake of ease and convenience, you take a position on the topic. You say that whichever viewpoint prevails in silence gets to keep prevailing. You need to own that choice. BTW, the banner ad at the bottom of my screen as I'm typing these word says "Israel under attack!" So I guess outright political provocation is fine on the site as long as you can pay for the privilege.
-
Solid upside move. Potentially troubling clubhouse move for an organization whose whole identity is putting the team ahead of selfish interests and actions. https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/giants-broadcaster-goes-ballistic-pitchers-210242226.html?guccounter=1 Walker can believe whatever he wants to believe. If he keeps going rogue to make it all about him, that's a different story. In related news, the Brewers have a lot of LGBTQ+ fans, just like every other team does in the 21st century. Walker says his gesture wasn't about putting those fans down, but in context it's easy to see why they would take it that way. I hope the Brewers remain committed to creating a welcoming and inclusive environment for all their fans.
- 9 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- ryan walker
- blake holub
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Brewers representation on all-MLB is awesome, so this is more of an observation than a complaint, but Garrett Mitchell had a meaningfully better season than Jordan Walker by both WAR systems, because Mitchell is a very good defensive centerfielder while Walker is a very bad defensive rightfielder.
-
No. The idea that anyone they could likely go out and sign is any less a “question mark” than the guys they already have is just shiny object syndrome.
-
This is a classic “go get somebody for the sake of going and getting somebody” argument. It emphasizes only the case against Vaughn while ignoring the case for him (improved across the board since joining the Brewers, a year removed from the hamate injury, affordable if Bauers leaves). It all but ignores Burke and Adams, and comparing them to Pratt a year ago ignores how much more advanced they are than he was. The Brewers at 1b have a capable veteran and three strong prospects in the upper minors. They don’t need to just go get somebody.
-
Didn’t we feel pretty much the same way about Adames that we feel about Contreras — productive player, irreplaceable leader? We came through that okay. Two things make me like the idea of extending William: the very real possibility that he’s a world-historic postseason assassin, and the almost mystical reverence the pitchers have for him. Those are two big pluses. Everything else for me is a minus. Catchers age horribly. He’s a good but very streaky offensive player who has never been great and hasn’t improved. His defense mostly grades out as mediocre. His game-calling is hard to defend. He’s gotten good at throwing out base-stealers, but not so good that it overcomes his flaws. It’s true that we don’t have an obvious replacement in house right now. But good teams find guys. We found William Contreras. I would not trade him this winter. Play out his team control like we did with Adames. That gives us another year of runway to work on replacing him.
-
I think they have viable solutions in house for every potential roster hole. The problems are just some holes in what we know, which may or may not also be holes in what the organization knows: Catcher: How do Quero’s shoulder and Naylor’s bat look once spring training finally starts? I assume Contreras will be back for a final season. First base: do you give Bauers the QO? I don’t see why not. He’ll probably get a multi-year offer somewhere; if he takes the QO, the Brewers can deal for a year financially, and he’s probably worth it. Does Vaughn’s power return a year out from the hamate injury? If so, he’s a perfectly credible regular. If Bauers takes the QO, then just trade Vaughn. Then you’ve got three guys in Adams, Burke, and Fischer, who are very strong prospects with upper minors experience already. When is one or more of them ready? Third base: Ortiz and Hamilton make a perfectly fine platoon. (BTW, I think it’s much more likely that Ortiz plays significant innings at shortstop for the Brewers in 2027 than Williams.) Made is a question of when rather than if. Outfield: For the Brewers more than other teams, you can look at the outfield holistically, because most of these guys can move around. I think this is actually where the roster may be softest. The only fully trustworthy regular is Chourio. Can Mitchell stay healthy and effective? Can Frelick return to health and effectiveness? Will Lara hit enough yet to play regularly? Are you comfortable with Lockridge as your next depth option? This is where I think Williams might find a place if they think he’s ready to help. DH: Does Yelich collapse? If so, you’ve got plenty of guys who could stand to be rotated through this spot. Pitching: We should be just fine barring bad health news. Biggest questions in the rotation are whether they can get Harrison back to mid-rotation form and if/ how soon Priester can come back strong. Also, is Hardin ready to contribute?Then it’s just a question of which of the depth guys develops fastest. In the bullpen, the big question is whether they trade Megill and bump Uribe rebate up to closer. Wagoner appears ready to contribute.
- 18 replies
-
- andrew vaughn
- joey ortiz
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Where does this team rank in past WS Champions
gregmag replied to Ewitkows1's topic in Milwaukee Brewers Talk
I took a quick look at World Series winning teams’ regular season fWAR over the past 20 years (ignoring 2020 as all reasonable people should).The 2026 Brewers put up 50.4 fWAR. Seven winners put up more fWAR: the three Red Sox champs, the two Astros champs, the 2009 Yankees, and the 2016 Cubs. So that’s three repeat champs (the Yankees won recently before the 20-year window) — three of the four big-market behemoths of the 21st century — and our friends to the south. The Dodgers are a strange story. The 2024 champs posted about 47 fWAR, the 2025 repeaters who waxed the Brewers only 42. The 2026 iteration was the best version, posting 52.6 fWAR, but it didn’t matter. (BTW, the 2025 Brewers put up more fWAR than the Dodgers, 47.1). The only other repeat champs in this period, the 2010-2014 even-year Giants, put up the worst, third-worst, and fifth-worst fWARs of the 19 winners. (Second and fourth on that ignominious list are the 2011 Cardinals and 2021 Braves, both of course infamous Brewers heartbreakers.) This all likely means nothing. However, it seems a little interesting that the most talented teams have been repeat winners, and the less talented teams have been one and done, with the exceptions in either direction of the Cubs and Giants. The 2026 Brewers weren’t miles better than the 2019 Nationals or 2021 Rangers, but they were better. It seems like the Brewers, by this measure, are in a very realistic position to contend for more titles in the next several years, especially when you consider how young their core is and how little value they’re losing to free agency this winter. -
JoJo Romero: Bullpen Behemoth Or Trade Package Afterthought?
gregmag replied to Jason Wang's topic in Milwaukee Brewers Talk
May ranged from barely passable to bad. He couldn’t even give us length. Brewers in postseason games started by anyone other than Dustin May: 11-0. Brewers in postseason games started by Dustin May: 0-2. Brewers pitchers with worse postseason ERAs than May’s appalling 5.73: Woodruff and Drohan, each of whom only pitched one inning to May’s 11 and each of whom had a reasonable excuse for not pitching better. May constantly looked scared and/or annoyed, and I never heard anyone say a kind word about him, unless “his stuff is theoretically good“ counts as kind. He’s in the running for my least favorite Brewer since Matt Garza, which i’ll admit is a little unfair to May in that we only had to put up with him for a couple of months. The May part of the trade was an abject failure, a classic stupid deadline overpay for a player who was meaningless at very best. The Romero part of the trade almost makes up for the May part. Yes, he actually took the loss in that ill-fated May start in San Diego, but a non-power hitter beat him on a perfectly good pitch. If you give him that one Mulligan, he was nails the rest of the postseason. Ultimately I still hate the trade, because I’m not convinced the Brewers actually needed Romero as opposed to getting one of their other guys going – but Romero did what he did, and what he did helped meaningfully to win a championship. -
This is exactly where I am. Baseball history is littered with successful teams that got less successful by running it back. The whole foundation of the Brewers’ success is understanding the difference between the past and the future. Catchers age terribly. I think Molina was vastly overhyped, but even if we take Molina‘s early 30s as a positive example, there’s no particular reason to think Contreras will have similar success.
-
An article fully worthy of a championship team. My favorite Brewers interview moment since Brice Turang sadly stopped sounding like a less articulate Jeff Spicoli came tonight from Cooper Pratt, looking thoroughly bewildered: “It only took four months.”
- 7 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- postseason
- jacob misiorowski
- (and 4 more)

