Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted

Deals like this make me so thankful that the Brewers have placed a priority on drafting and developing starting pitching and acquiring young, controllable starters in nearly every high-end trade they've made over the last few seasons. I would not be surprised whatsoever to see a guy like Brandon Sproat put up better results than May for the next three years, at less than 10% of May's total salary.

Posted

May did enough along with Romero that the deal was a net loss, but not a cosmically bad one. Winning the WS puts it into the category of things to be forgotten. Not all trades are going to work out the way you want when it comes to performance. But definitely both the need for the trade and the amount of the FA signing reinforce the need for trying have as much pitching depth in the offseason as possible since it is way too expensive at the deadline

  • Like 4
Posted

The way I see it, the Brewers FO was not sure they could get over the hump of the Dodgers in the playoffs, especially when they added Skubal. 

but also, on paper, this could be the Brewers best team to go for it, and there was certainly pressure from the media and murmers from the fanbase and likely promises within the org they were serious. The Dodgers put their chips in. The Cubs put their chips in. So did the Padres.

If the brewers didnt put their chips in and didnt make it, that decision would forever be questioned by the media and by the fanbase and possibly within the org. 

To maintain trust in the FO, they had to make some move and the caliber of players we lost like Ragsdale were already gone, no matter what.  They dealt away depth, instead of giving of away Henderson, Pena and Adamczewski for a rental.  Even in dealing those guys away, there was a criticism of not doing enough to seriously compete with the Dodgers.

With 20/20 hindsight, there were better choices than May and we probably didnt need him to win it all anyways. You cant win every gamble, but you have to take some risks to win and to maintain organizational trust.

So yes, there were more "perfect" moves that could have been made, but in the ended we were very fortunate to walk away with the vast majority of our farm still in tact and a World Championship.

  • Like 2
Community Moderator
Posted
37 minutes ago, igor67 said:

May did enough along with Romero that the deal was a net loss, but not a cosmically bad one. Winning the WS puts it into the category of things to be forgotten. Not all trades are going to work out the way you want when it comes to performance. But definitely both the need for the trade and the amount of the FA signing reinforce the need for trying have as much pitching depth in the offseason as possible since it is way too expensive at the deadline

Yeah the FO had the right calculus of "we might have a WS winning team here so let's make 100% sure that we do". Then the wheels fell off of Harrison and it turned out we really needed both May and Romero. 

Romero was the really smart one, having that extra lefty in the pen was huge. We basically got him as a throw in because he was injured and wasn't going to be all that useful to teams fighting for playoff spots. 

There were a some bad deadline acquisitions for starters. The good ones ended up being Skubal (duh), Freddy, and Holmes. Not surprisingly we were rumored to be in on all of them and not on any of the ones that failed (Mize, Gausman, Castillo), another data point for how smart this FO is. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Totally understandable that May's getting 3/52.5.  I mean, he's bad, but at least he's injury prone.

Absolute stink bomb of a trade.  There is no theory under which May was useful to the Brewers.  Any warm body could have pitched his bad innings badly.  Getting Romero was sneaky brilliant, but Romero alone was worth Ragsdale at most.  I can't believe an organization as smart as the Brewers made the trade to satisfy public pressure to "go for it," because that would be cowardly and idiotic -- but if that was their motive, they should hang May's stats on a prominent wall to deter them any time they're tempted to make another stupid deadline trade, which is to say just about any deadline trade.

I hope May does fine I guess, but I'm very glad to be rid of him.

Posted
2 hours ago, Ron Robinsons Beard said:

Deals like this make me so thankful that the Brewers have placed a priority on drafting and developing starting pitching and acquiring young, controllable starters in nearly every high-end trade they've made over the last few seasons. I would not be surprised whatsoever to see a guy like Brandon Sproat put up better results than May for the next three years, at less than 10% of May's total salary.

When I found out that the QB for the Wisconsin badgers (who was benched) makes more money that Miz, gasser and Henderson combined.   Who basically were the starting rotation of the WORLD SERIES WINNERS.    
 

something is broken in sports.    Either baseball or college football.    I will let you decide

Community Moderator
Posted
50 minutes ago, gregmag said:

Totally understandable that May's getting 3/52.5.  I mean, he's bad, but at least he's injury prone.

Absolute stink bomb of a trade.  There is no theory under which May was useful to the Brewers.  Any warm body could have pitched his bad innings badly.  Getting Romero was sneaky brilliant, but Romero alone was worth Ragsdale at most.  I can't believe an organization as smart as the Brewers made the trade to satisfy public pressure to "go for it," because that would be cowardly and idiotic -- but if that was their motive, they should hang May's stats on a prominent wall to deter them any time they're tempted to make another stupid deadline trade, which is to say just about any deadline trade.

I hope May does fine I guess, but I'm very glad to be rid of him.

In this case the end justifies the means. 

  • Like 1
Posted

May was bad. Very, very bad. Had the Brewers not won the World Series, or even played in it, not a soul would still be claiming this stuff about how he "did his job" etc. The only thing preventing his time as a Brewer from being a disaster is the fact that they won the World Series in spite of him. 

I consider his time here a true phenomenon. I've never seen people try so hard to defend someone who played so poorly and had literally 0 ties to the fans or team. It's not like he tailed off after 3 great years here. I could understand that.  

Remove the name and just examine his numbers in Milwaukee. Any sane person would look at that line and assume it was a guy we kicked off the MLB roster in May. 

  • Like 3
Posted
6 hours ago, liveforoctober said:

I'll never forget sitting and talking with a White Sox scout during a TRats game in the early 2000s.

That would have been when the T-Rats belonged to the Mariners.  The T-Rats weren't part of the Brewers organization until 2009.

"I'm sick of runnin' from these wimps!" Ajax - The WARRIORS
Posted
3 hours ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

If the goal was to do what May did, they could have done with any shuttle bus from Nashville. You don't give up what the Brewers did unless you think May is going to meaningfully contribute, which he did not.

Exactly, I don't understand why people keep saying May was acquired just to eat innings.  I don't buy that for a second.  They needed a number 3 pitcher in the rotation at that time, and no one can tell me that isn't the reason we got him, to be our #3 in the playoffs.  Thankfully, Gasser did what he did, or we would have had some trouble...

  • Like 1
"I'm sick of runnin' from these wimps!" Ajax - The WARRIORS
Posted
6 minutes ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

May was bad. Very, very bad. Had the Brewers not won the World Series, or even played in it, not a soul would still be claiming this stuff about how he "did his job" etc. The only thing preventing his time as a Brewer from being a disaster is the fact that they won the World Series in spite of him. 

I consider his time here a true phenomenon. I've never seen people try so hard to defend someone who played so poorly and had literally 0 ties to the fans or team. It's not like he tailed off after 3 great years here. I could understand that.  

Remove the name and just examine his numbers in Milwaukee. Any sane person would look at that line and assume it was a guy we kicked off the MLB roster in May. 

I find it the exact opposite. Not saying it is your case but weird how so many people hate this guy for no reason and making up stuff just to make him look bad. Just really bizarre behavior to not personally like a guy and say untrue things just because some prospects are gone even though he had nothing to do with what prospects were given up for him. Hate Matt Arnold for it.

Posted

I don't think anyone hates Dustin May, the person.

I think a lot of people hate the trade that brought him here.

Speaking for myself, I have nothing against Dustin May, I hope he kicks ass with the Sox, but I'm glad he signed someplace other than Milwaukee for that kind of cash.

  • Like 2
"I'm sick of runnin' from these wimps!" Ajax - The WARRIORS
Posted
5 minutes ago, Outlander said:

I find it the exact opposite. Not saying it is your case but weird how so many people hate this guy for no reason and making up stuff just to make him look bad. Just really bizarre behavior to not personally like a guy and say untrue things just because some prospects are gone even though he had nothing to do with what prospects were given up for him. Hate Matt Arnold for it.

I don't hate him at all, but it isn't for "no reason." He was just a very bad Milwaukee Brewer. I was hoping every single time they trotted him out there that he would find the magic. 

But he was just bad. I don't know if his ERA finished under 6 including the postseason.  Guy just wasn't good, the trade sucked, luckily it didn't cost us a bad outcome. 

Community Moderator
Posted
7 minutes ago, TURBO said:

Exactly, I don't understand why people keep saying May was acquired just to eat innings.  I don't buy that for a second.  They needed a number 3 pitcher in the rotation at that time, and no one can tell me that isn't the reason we got him, to be our #3 in the playoffs.  Thankfully, Gasser did what he did, or we would have had some trouble...

He was 100% acquired to eat innings in the regular season. Miz and Harrison (the presumed #2 playoff starter on August 3) both had to be load managed and the division and #1 seed weren't settled at all. We had both Sproat and Drohan in the rotation at the time. 

In my view both of the following are true:

- We needed to acquire one of the list of ~6-7 rental starters that were available at the deadline
- May sucked as a Brewer

You also can't separate May and Romero, they were acquired as a package. Who knows if we could have gotten just Romero and not May. 

If we're in the same situation again, the FO would absolutely have the same wish list of a starter, a lefty reliever, and a righty reliever. 

Posted
4 hours ago, Ron Robinsons Beard said:

His main role was to keep innings off the team's top young arms. It could be argued that a guy like Coleman Crow may have been able to do the same thing, though.

I can see the Brewers, or any other organization for that matter, thinking that for two months May would fill the above role with more effectiveness than Crow. Did he? We'll never know, probably not.

As for the contract........maybe his agent sent out his start in Milwaukee in late May & just put it on a loop (fun fact, the guy who replaced him that day & blew the save was one Jo Jo Romero).

Posted

Probably some semantics on "just to eat innings" going on there.   Yes, he definitely was needed to do that, but its also fair to say the expected more of him than just eating innings.      To many 'just eat innings' probably means anybody to just be out there basically as AAAA type fodder.  I think its fair to say they likely got him because the innings did need to be ate, but by getting him rather than a cheaper lower level guy (think Quintana 4 years ago type guy) they were probably hoping he'd be the #3 starter in the playoffs.  Instead he was the #4 and really only a one time through lineup guy.     To me, I think the results on him fall in the middle of the extremes being discussed.  

  • Like 1
Posted
31 minutes ago, TURBO said:

That would have been when the T-Rats belonged to the Mariners.  The T-Rats weren't part of the Brewers organization until 2009.

Correct, we were a Mariners' affiliate. A lot of opposing scouts came through to watch guys.

Posted
1 minute ago, tmwiese55 said:

Probably some semantics on "just to eat innings" going on there.   Yes, he definitely was needed to do that, but its also fair to say the expected more of him than just eating innings.      To many 'just eat innings' probably means anybody to just be out there basically as AAAA type fodder.  I think its fair to say they likely got him because the innings did need to be ate, but by getting him rather than a cheaper lower level guy (think Quintana 4 years ago type guy) they were probably hoping he'd be the #3 starter in the playoffs.  Instead he was the #4 and really only a one time through lineup guy.     To me, I think the results on him fall in the middle of the extremes being discussed.  

And had we known Robert Gasser was going to turn into a modern-day version of Jerry Koosman, the #3 starter hopes wouldn't have been necessary.

Regarding this thread, yeah, somewhere btwn the two extremes. The prospect price paid for him will always be a sticking point with people though, which I totally understand.

  • Like 1
Posted
15 minutes ago, owbc said:

He was 100% acquired to eat innings in the regular season.

Any SP is acquired to "eat innings." Doing it at a 6 ERA pace is not what that expression means. They got May to have another quality arm in the rotation to load manage and be competitive when he pitched. I find it pretty funny that Suppan made that expression famous in Milwaukee and then May came along and offered up very Suppan results.

I think the Brewers would have been just fine with May showing up, pitching 5 innings of 2 or 3 ER every time out, not impressing anyone but just being a guy. But he was worse than that.

Posted
1 hour ago, willie key said:

When I found out that the QB for the Wisconsin badgers (who was benched) makes more money that Miz, gasser and Henderson combined.   Who basically were the starting rotation of the WORLD SERIES WINNERS.    
 

something is broken in sports.    Either baseball or college football.    I will let you decide

The youth of the three pitchers & their not having had a chance at their 'payday' yet has everything to do with that. 

As to the last part, can I choose "both"?

Posted
55 minutes ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

May was bad. Very, very bad. Had the Brewers not won the World Series, or even played in it, not a soul would still be claiming this stuff about how he "did his job" etc. The only thing preventing his time as a Brewer from being a disaster is the fact that they won the World Series in spite of him. 

I consider his time here a true phenomenon. I've never seen people try so hard to defend someone who played so poorly and had literally 0 ties to the fans or team. It's not like he tailed off after 3 great years here. I could understand that.  

Remove the name and just examine his numbers in Milwaukee. Any sane person would look at that line and assume it was a guy we kicked off the MLB roster in May. 

👍 (because they only let me like your post once)

As far as "eating innings",  In 2 months, he started 10 games and threw 36.2 innings. I know in today's game the standard for innings has been lowered, but he wasn't exactly a workhorse. 

*  Feel the need to add that Romero was really good, and THE BREWERS WON THE WORLD SERIES!  So I'm not going to hate on Arnold for the trade.  May was also serviceable (threw an important inning in game 2 alonf with Romero) in the WS.

Posted
26 minutes ago, tmwiese55 said:

Probably some semantics on "just to eat innings" going on there.   Yes, he definitely was needed to do that, but its also fair to say the expected more of him than just eating innings.      To many 'just eat innings' probably means anybody to just be out there basically as AAAA type fodder.  I think its fair to say they likely got him because the innings did need to be ate, but by getting him rather than a cheaper lower level guy (think Quintana 4 years ago type guy) they were probably hoping he'd be the #3 starter in the playoffs.  Instead he was the #4 and really only a one time through lineup guy.     To me, I think the results on him fall in the middle of the extremes being discussed.  

They definitely wanted him to eat innings but a "just eat innings" guy is a Frankie Montas or Aaron Civale type of acquisition where you're giving up limited value to make the trade. They certainly had bigger aspirations for May than how he performed.

  • Like 2
Posted
1 hour ago, Lucas O. said:

 They certainly had bigger aspirations for May than how he performed.

Based on what they gave up to get him, you are 100% correct!

You don't give up a Frias and/or Ragsdale for a guy whose only purpose is to eat innings.

"I'm sick of runnin' from these wimps!" Ajax - The WARRIORS
Posted

My hope is that now they’ve gotten over the hump and won the World Series, the Brewers won’t feel as much urgency at trade deadlines to make a deal if only a bad deal is on the table. 

I think there’s something to that, maybe a little less pressure for the front office, especially being able to look back and pretty confidently say that the team you assembled in May, June, and July actually was indeed already good enough, even with the Dodgers getting Skubal. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...