Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
  • Brewers Draft Coverage

    2024 MLB Draft Day 3 Thread


    Jeremy Nygaard

    Ten rounds down, ten rounds to go for the 2024 MLB Draft. It's been a life-changing event for 315 young men so far; there will be 300 more lives changed on Tuesday afternoon. Keep it tuned to Brewer Fanatic for live updates throughout the remainder of the draft.

    Brewers Video

    Today's portion of the draft, which will conclude with rounds 11 through 20, will begin at 1 p.m. CT.

    Keep up to date with the Brewers Draft Tracker

    One reminder: players selected on Day 3 can sign for up to $150,000 without it impacting the team's bonus pool. Any dollars above that threshold will count toward the cap. For example, if a player today signs for $200k, it will count $50k toward the team's bonus pool.

    What do you think after the first two days? Leave your thoughts below.

    11 (335) - Caedmon Parker, RHP, TCU
    21 years old. 6-4, 190. 

    Likely reliever. Returned from Tommy John surgery in 2024.

    12 (365) - Tyson Hardin, RHP, Mississippi State
    22 years old. 6-2, 185.  (Senior)

    13 (395) - Joey Broughton, LHP, Northville (MI) HS
    18 years old. 6-2, 187.

    14 (425) - James Nunnallee, C, Lightridge (VA) HS
    18 years old. 6-0, 180. #146 on the Consensus Big Board

    Nunnallee is a prep hitter committed to Virginia who has seen time behind the plate and in the outfield. Nunnallee has a solid overall offensive tool set with a good approach and solid swing decisions. He has fast hands and his swing produces mostly gap power at present. This is an offensive profile with a solid floor that could produce average and power tools.
    Nunnallee is solid enough at catcher but there's work to do defensively if he's to stick behind the plate. There's enough in the offensive profile if he doesn't to play in the outfield.
    - Consensus Big Board

    15 (455) - Travis Smith, RHP, Kentucky
    21 years old. 6-4, 220. #250 on the Consensus Big Board

    One of Kentucky's top high school prospects in 2021, Smith's career was placed on hold when he required both Tommy John and heart surgery. After redshirting at Kentucky in 2022, he worked his way into the Wildcats' weekend rotation by the end of last season and threw four shutout innings in a regional playoff game against Ball State. He flashed top-three-rounds stuff this spring, though he missed a start with soreness in late March, worked out of the bullpen afterward and barely pitched in the final two months. Smith's two-seam fastball operates at 93-95 mph and tops out at 97, featuring heavy life that induces a lot of ground-ball contact. His high-spin slider parks at 85 mph and peaks at 89 with both horizontal and vertical action, and he also can turn it into a low-90s cutter. He's still developing feel for a sinking changeup that's too firm in the upper 80s. As he puts his elbow reconstruction further behind him, Smith has improved his strength and conditioning and now carries 220 pounds on his 6-foot-4 frame. He's also showing more aptitude for locating and sequencing his pitches. If he stays on track toward developing two plus offerings and average control, he could be a mid-rotation starter. - MLB.com

    16 (485) - Jayden Dubanewicz, RHP, Marjory Stoneman Douglas (FL) HS
    18 years old. 6-3, 160.

    17 (515) - Cooper Malamazian, SS, Nazareth Academy (IL)
    18 years old. 6-1, 185.

    18 (545) - Tyler Renz, RHP, Fox Lane (NY) HS
    17 years old. 6-4, 180.

    19 (575) - Noah Wech, RHP, Manitowoc Lincoln (WI) HS
    22 years old. 6-2. 205.

    20 (605) - Henry Brummel, RHP, Pontiac Township (IL) HS
    23 years old. 6-4, 202. 


    If you've missed anything from the previous two days, you can find it below.

    1 (17) - Braylon Payne, OF, Elkins (TX) HS
    17 years old. 6-2, 186. #56 on the Consensus Big Board
    Draft Article / Draft Tracker

    1C (34) - Blake Burke, 1B, Tennessee
    21 years old. 6-3, 236. #49 on the Consensus Big Board
    Draft Article / Draft Tracker

    2 (51) - Bryce Meccage, RHP, The Pennington School (NJ)
    18 years old. 6-4, 210. #63 on the Consensus Big Board
    Draft Article / Draft Tracker

    2C (59) - Chris Levonas, RHP, Christian Brothers Academy (NJ)
    18 years old. 6-2, 170. #79 on the Consensus Big Board
    Draft Article / Draft Tracker 

    3 (93) - Jaron DeBerry, RHP, Dallas Baptist
    21 years old. 6-3, 178. (Senior) 

    4 (123) - Marco Dinges, C, Florida State
    20 years old. 6-0, 205.

    5 (156)John Holobetz, P, Old Dominion
    21 years old. 6-3, 190.

    6 (185) - Chandler Welch, RHP, Tulane
    21 years old. 6-0, 200.

    7 (215) - Mason Molina, LHP, Arkansas
    21 years old. 6-2, 230. #218 on the Consensus Big Board

    8 (245)Sam Garcia, LHP, Oklahoma State
    22 years old. 6-4, 218. (Senior)

    9 (275) - Griffin Tobias, RHP, Lake Central (IN) HS
    18 years old. 6-0, 185. 

    10 (305)Ethan Dorchies, RHP, Cary-Grove (IL) HS
    17 years old. 6-4, 200.  


    Bonus Pool Situation

    brewers.png


    Check out our 2026 mock draft board, updated regularly, and with detailed player write-ups!

    View The Mock Draft Board

    Follow Brewer Fanatic For Milwaukee Brewers News & Analysis

    Recent Brewers Articles

    Recent Brewers Videos

    Brewers Top Prospects

    Josh Adamczewski

    Wisconsin Timber Rattlers - A+, IF
    The still-just-20-year-old is off to a powerful start in Wisconsin. He has nine hits in his first 10 games. He's hitting .310/.474/..828 (1.302) with 5 home runs and 11 RBI.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    12 hours ago, igor67 said:

    Especially if I am a pitcher, I would find it hard to pass up a solid 6+ figure offer from the Brewers. Get premier development. A chance to get to MLB faster and the low minors salaries aren't as terrible anymore. And probably better care in case of an injury.

     

    In terms of draft strategy I expect that their pattern will again shift in a few years as industry patterns change. About the only constant has been liking up the middle prospects for awhile now.

    Maybe Milwaukee sees that with the extra minors pay, more HS picks will sign with the 150k or more signing bonus.  There's also blocking other teams from drafting some of these kids. Signed or not.

    FanGraphs Day Two and Three Draft Roundup had a blurb on the Brewers approach...

    "The Brewers followed up on their high school-heavy 2023 draft with an even younger group this year, and it reveals an interesting strategy. Their first round pick, Braylon Payne, was generally seen as a second-round prospect. His bonus is likely to be well below the $4.5 million slot value of his pick, with some amount of the excess pool space diverted to the high school pitching prospects they selected in the second and Comp B rounds, New Jersey high schoolers Bryce Meccage and Chris Levonas. They also popped high schoolers in rounds nine and 10, and then took several on Day Three. Not all of these guys are going to sign but several of them will. Recall last year that Brewers got Cooper Pratt’s deal done for $1.3 million in the sixth round and then also signed multiple high schoolers for between $250,000-$550,000 on Day Three of the draft. Day Three picks don’t have bonus slots that reduce your team’s pool if the player doesn’t sign, so aside from a little opportunity cost (the college guy they’d have otherwise taken in round 14 or whatever), the Brewers can now negotiate with a bunch of higher-upside high school players between now and the signing deadline and decide what combination of bonuses and players gives them the best overall class.

    Several teams do a version of this every year, but nobody does it to this degree. Whether it was precipitated by the nature of this particular draft class or just how the board fell in the first round (i.e. the Brewers didn’t like who was left on the board, so they pivoted to this strategy), we just don’t know."

    • Like 3
    • Love 1

    We only hear of minor league contracts in regards to signing bonuses, but what’s stopping teams from paying guys more during the contract itself rather than using bonus money?

    Example: Sign for 150k less, and we will pay you 50k more per year?
     

    Feel like this would come in handy in rounds 11-20, and especially with high schoolers.

    **EDIT** From what I’ve found on google, it looks like your first contract season is paid $1,100/month, and after that season it’s all open to negotiation (with higher minimums at each level).

    27 minutes ago, snoogans8056 said:

    We only hear of minor league contracts in regards to signing bonuses, but what’s stopping teams from paying guys more during the contract itself rather than using bonus money?

    Example: Sign for 150k less, and we will pay you 50k more per year?
     

    Feel like this would come in handy in rounds 11-20, and especially with high schoolers.

    **EDIT** From what I’ve found on google, it looks like your first contract season is paid $1,100/month, and after that season it’s all open to negotiation (with higher minimums at each level).

    Oooohh, this is an excellent question. Essentially promising guys "perks" for signing. Not unlike old-school college football recruiting.

    I have to think that teams have done this before, and that MLB has controlled for it in some way. It could even be accomplished by some kind of internal memo from the Commissioner's Office, "Hey guys, we see what you're doing and you've got to knock it off, or we'll need to add it to the next CBA, which is annoying for all of us."




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...