I am not seeing the same player when I see these two. First off to say that they were expected to be the same is not true. Weeks had a much higher upside. I think that Phillips has for sure broken out, but again he only had a .751 OPS in his "breakout" season last year, and a OPS at .800 this year. Comparing their seasons last year Weeks actually had a better season with a .767 OPS. Just give Weeks time and throw away what he has done this season, he will not dissapoint you.