I've watched the play probably 20 times on my dvr and I don't see how there is any way Casey could've beat Phillips to the bag. McGehee was playing deep and had to wait back after a big bounce and when he gloved the ball Phillips was only a step to his left with a full head of steam and Casey was at a stand still after fielding the chopper. No, his only plays were to commit to trying to tag out the runner or just taking the out at first. Had he decided to charge the ball harder, Phillips could've ran safely right behind him.