So you would trade a Top 15 prospect who is possibly one of our very very few star potential players for a #50-#75 prospect just because they are at a position of need? Despite such player probably being even less of a sure thing and possess a ceiling half that of Brinson? I also don't get the attention to LHH. We have plenty of those coming through the ranks I don't think we need to downgrade to find one. If we made such a trade my heartbeat may quite frankly stop. No, 1) Just because MLB.com, some other service, or you have Brinson as a Top 15 prospect doesn't mean that he is one. Lots of All-Stars were never Top 100 prospects, lots of Top 50 prospects never became All-Stars. Byron Buxton was the #1 prospect across the board in 2014 but has found the majors so far to be tough sledding, Matt Wieters was the #1 prospect across the board in 2009, and Delmon Young was top-3 for four years in a row; however, Carlos Gomez (and, small sample, so far Keon Broxton) and Jonathan Lucroy have had more productive careers despite not being nearly as heralded as "prospects". Anyone who takes BA, MLB, or BP rankings as gospel is a fool. No one had Woodruff on their list last year despite scouting reports of him regularly working upper 90's; this year he is hitting 98 late in games and led all of MiLB in strikeouts, and should be on everyone's list. (If someone doesn't think that's TOR potential, then I don't know what is.) B) I think Brinson's performance at AAA was a bit of a small sample error because a walk rate of 2.1% does not suggest that success is sustainable; the larger sample - injured or not - suggests the AAA performance was a bit of an outlier (walk rate <5% on the season). In 2015 his great performance was in the Cal League, a notorious hitters league (see: reaction to potential Brewers A+ team in Cal League a few months ago), and his great performance in 2016 was in the PCL. I think he is a Top 100 prospect, but not a Top 15 prospect, thus why I suggested a swap for a Top 75 prospect - because that's what I think he is.