Value wise the only way this trade works out in the Brewer's favor on it's own merits is if Lawrie ends up being a below average MLB player, which seems unlikely at this point in time. The combination of trades that Melvin made have worked out wonderfully, but both the Marcum and Greinke deals on their own were significant overpays. It's difficult to separate the various deals and view them independently, especially given the success of the MLB team this season, but it's not impossible to be somewhat objective and evaluate the deals on their own merits. I believe the sum of deals is better than the individual parts, the Morgan trade was at least as important to the MLB club as the Marcum trade, and it was infinitely more cost effective. I'll take the two trades, regardless of how much some people think the Brewers overpaid, 100% of the time when put in the context of this being Fielder's last season in Milwaukee. Would I like to have kept Lawrie? Sure, but I'd rather make the playoffs and have a team with a shot at doing some playoff damage than treading water for multiple seasons. The trades Melvin made this year have made the MLB team so much better than it would have been. Without Greinke and Marcum, the Brewers don't make the playoffs this year, and with Lawrie and company from the other trades, the Brewers don't make the playoffs in future years once Fielder leaves if the pitching still isn't addressed.