I know he's a consensus top 5. But let's look over the top 5 from 2016's mid-season poll (viewtopic.php?f=64&t=34472) - since I think five years is a good time to judge a prospects list: 1. Orlando Arcia 2. Lewis Brinson 3. Josh Hader 4. Luis Ortiz 5. Phil Bickford Only one - Josh Hader - is a significant contributor on the Brewers roster. Arcia was a good-field sometimes-hit shortstop. He got dealt to the Braves for two pitchers, one of whom was DFAed. Brinson was part of the package to land Yelich, so he was useful in that regard, but how has he done in the majors? Well, this year he cracked a .700 OPS. Ortiz pitched less than six innings in the majors in 2018-2019, and is currently laboring in the Texas Rangers' system. Brinson was DFAed, and picked up by the Dodgers. Let's look at who is on the roster from that top 25: Brandon Woodruff made that Top 25... at #13. Yet he's a co-ace of the rotation. Freddy Peralta, also in the Big 3, was at #16. Devin Williams, 2020 Rookie of the Year, was #19. Corbin Burnes was at #22. Brent Suter was at #26 in that poll. Tyrone Taylor was #30 Adrian Houser, our #4 starter was tied for #46 - and had fallen 27 spots. My top 5? - viewtopic.php?p=999759#p999759 1. Brent Suter 2. Josh Hader 3. Isan Diaz 4. Lucas Erceg 5. Phil Bickford Suter and Hader are both key parts of the Brewers bullpen. Diaz, like Brinson from the consensus top 5, was part of the package for Yelich. Erceg's best hope is to master the Brooks Keischnick routine. Bickford... well, he's with the Dodgers. I'll also add my note about Arcia in that ballot. 14. SS Orlando Arcia – The glove is there, but offensive performance at Colorado Springs raises questions. In addition, there's one other benefit you can get from the stats: You can see similarities from the past, and perhaps figure out if you're at a time to sell high. Looking at the numbers from both Arcia and Turang, I'm seeing both with a walk-rate drop from A+ to AA. I'm seeing what looks like offensive struggles at AAA (small sample in Turang's case). In the case of Turang, the OBP went DOWN 38 points in AA despite an eight-point rise in the batting average. Arcia saw his OBP go up ONE point when the batting average climbed 18 points. So, yeah, I'll stand by my decision to offer the D-Backs Turang for Escobar, even up. It keeps the guy I really liked (Hummel) in the system, where he could help at RF/1B in 2022 and beyond, I don't have to deal Alberto Ciprian (hence, keeping the lottery ticket), and based on the stats, there's a good chance such a trade is selling a left-handed Orlando Arcia high when the Brewers have multiple young SS types (Urias and Adames) on the roster already, a decent 2B in Kolten Wong for another 2 years, plus competent infield options like Weston Wilson and Jamie Westbrook at AAA. Plus, there's always the chance to extend Escobar for 2-3 years to lessen the blow of dealing a "consensus top 5 prospect."