You are WAY too hung up on postseason performance. Every time you talk about a player, it seems like you bring up their playoff numbers, even if it was only one series. For one game, I'd go SP >>>>>>> position player >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Closer For a season, I'd go Position Player >>> SP >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Closer You don't need a great closer. You just need someone who is adequate. A mediocre closer is more than capable of protecting a lead for one inning, especially when a lot of those leads are greater than one run. The Brewers' problem is that every relief pitcher they have is awful. Additionally, the closer's role is dependent on the SP and position players actually handing him a lead in the 9th, and a narrow lead at that.