longball, You are correct in theory but the facts don't back you up. The pitching just isn't that good. From the perspective of Brewer fans that suffered with some awful staffs oveer the years, it looks good, but even last year the starters had the 6th best ERA in the NL even with some 50 games against the Cubs, Astros and Pirates. You are willing to pay an unlimited price for at best the 6th best rotation? That's foolish. If Greinke gets a Cain-like deal it could cripple the franchise for a decade. Even if he stays healthy and has a good solid 5-6 years, does that guaranty anything? Of course not. If he gets hurt or turns into a John Lackey, the money on his deal is dead money There's no guaranty that a Thornburg or Bradley couldn't do just as well for a lot less too. As for Weeks, frankly I've seen enough. Of all the guys drafted high in the wave that included Braun, Fielder, and Hart, Weeks is the one guy that really never reached his potential which was the highest of all those guys. As he approaches his 30th birthday, he continues to strike out at an alarming rate. He has the talent to hit .320 with 25-30 HR per year. Yet he can't crack .270. He will draw some walks, but now isn't even a threat to steal and many of those walks are because he can't put balls in play and eventually gets deep in counts. Fans aren't going to abandon this team if a Weeks is replaced by a Gennett. Fans love exciting new players. If they haven't yet realized it they soon will that we've seen the best of what Weeks has and he's never going to be that elite player.